vault/enos/enos-scenario-autopilot.hcl
Ryan Cragun 89e9e0f2cd
VAULT-28307 enos: allow arm64 fips1402 and hsm editions (#27571)
In preperation for arm64 builds of hsm, fips1402, and hsm.fips1402
editions of Vault Enterprise we'll allow them in our test scenarios.

Signed-off-by: Ryan Cragun <me@ryan.ec>
2024-06-21 15:24:46 -06:00

827 lines
27 KiB
HCL

# Copyright (c) HashiCorp, Inc.
# SPDX-License-Identifier: BUSL-1.1
scenario "autopilot" {
description = <<-EOF
The autopilot scenario verifies autopilot upgrades between previously released versions of
Vault Enterprise against another candidate build. The build can be a local branch, any CRT built
Vault Enterprise artifact saved to the local machine, or any CRT built Vault Enterprise artifact
in the stable channel in Artifactory.
The scenario creates a new Vault Cluster with a previously released version of Vault, mounts
various engines and creates data, then perform an Autopilot upgrade with any candidate build.
The scenario also performs standard baseline verification that is not specific to the autopilot
upgrade.
If you want to use the 'distro:leap' variant you must first accept SUSE's terms for the AWS
account. To verify that your account has agreed, sign-in to your AWS through Doormat,
and visit the following links to verify your subscription or subscribe:
arm64 AMI: https://aws.amazon.com/marketplace/server/procurement?productId=a516e959-df54-4035-bb1a-63599b7a6df9
amd64 AMI: https://aws.amazon.com/marketplace/server/procurement?productId=5535c495-72d4-4355-b169-54ffa874f849
EOF
matrix {
arch = global.archs
artifact_source = global.artifact_sources
artifact_type = global.artifact_types
config_mode = global.config_modes
distro = global.distros
edition = global.enterprise_editions
initial_version = global.upgrade_initial_versions_ent
seal = global.seals
# Autopilot wasn't available before 1.11.x
exclude {
initial_version = [for e in matrix.initial_version : e if semverconstraint(e, "<1.11.0-0")]
}
# Our local builder always creates bundles
exclude {
artifact_source = ["local"]
artifact_type = ["package"]
}
# There are no published versions of these artifacts yet. We'll update this to exclude older
# versions after our initial publication of these editions for arm64.
exclude {
arch = ["arm64"]
edition = ["ent.fips1402", "ent.hsm", "ent.hsm.fips1402"]
}
# PKCS#11 can only be used on ent.hsm and ent.hsm.fips1402.
exclude {
seal = ["pkcs11"]
edition = [for e in matrix.edition : e if !strcontains(e, "hsm")]
}
# arm64 AMIs are not offered for Leap
exclude {
distro = ["leap"]
arch = ["arm64"]
}
# softhsm packages not available for leap/sles. Enos support for softhsm on amzn2 is
# not implemented yet.
exclude {
seal = ["pkcs11"]
distro = ["amzn2", "leap", "sles"]
}
}
terraform_cli = terraform_cli.default
terraform = terraform.default
providers = [
provider.aws.default,
provider.enos.ec2_user,
provider.enos.ubuntu
]
locals {
artifact_path = matrix.artifact_source != "artifactory" ? abspath(var.vault_artifact_path) : null
enos_provider = {
amzn2 = provider.enos.ec2_user
leap = provider.enos.ec2_user
rhel = provider.enos.ec2_user
sles = provider.enos.ec2_user
ubuntu = provider.enos.ubuntu
}
manage_service = matrix.artifact_type == "bundle"
vault_install_dir = global.vault_install_dir[matrix.artifact_type]
vault_autopilot_default_max_leases = semverconstraint(matrix.initial_version, ">=1.16.0-0") ? "300000" : ""
}
step "build_vault" {
description = global.description.build_vault
module = "build_${matrix.artifact_source}"
variables {
build_tags = var.vault_local_build_tags != null ? var.vault_local_build_tags : global.build_tags[matrix.edition]
artifact_path = local.artifact_path
goarch = matrix.arch
goos = "linux"
artifactory_host = matrix.artifact_source == "artifactory" ? var.artifactory_host : null
artifactory_repo = matrix.artifact_source == "artifactory" ? var.artifactory_repo : null
artifactory_username = matrix.artifact_source == "artifactory" ? var.artifactory_username : null
artifactory_token = matrix.artifact_source == "artifactory" ? var.artifactory_token : null
arch = matrix.artifact_source == "artifactory" ? matrix.arch : null
product_version = var.vault_product_version
artifact_type = matrix.artifact_type
distro = matrix.artifact_source == "artifactory" ? matrix.distro : null
edition = matrix.artifact_source == "artifactory" ? matrix.edition : null
revision = var.vault_revision
}
}
step "ec2_info" {
description = global.description.ec2_info
module = module.ec2_info
}
step "create_vpc" {
description = global.description.create_vpc
module = module.create_vpc
variables {
common_tags = global.tags
}
}
step "read_license" {
description = global.description.read_vault_license
module = module.read_license
variables {
file_name = global.vault_license_path
}
}
step "create_seal_key" {
description = global.description.create_seal_key
module = "seal_${matrix.seal}"
depends_on = [step.create_vpc]
providers = {
enos = provider.enos.ubuntu
}
variables {
cluster_id = step.create_vpc.id
common_tags = global.tags
}
}
step "create_vault_cluster_targets" {
description = global.description.create_vault_cluster_targets
module = module.target_ec2_instances
depends_on = [step.create_vpc]
providers = {
enos = local.enos_provider[matrix.distro]
}
variables {
ami_id = step.ec2_info.ami_ids[matrix.arch][matrix.distro][global.distro_version[matrix.distro]]
cluster_tag_key = global.vault_tag_key
common_tags = global.tags
seal_key_names = step.create_seal_key.resource_names
vpc_id = step.create_vpc.id
}
}
step "create_vault_cluster_upgrade_targets" {
description = global.description.create_vault_cluster_targets
module = module.target_ec2_instances
depends_on = [step.create_vpc]
providers = {
enos = local.enos_provider[matrix.distro]
}
variables {
ami_id = step.ec2_info.ami_ids[matrix.arch][matrix.distro][global.distro_version[matrix.distro]]
common_tags = global.tags
cluster_name = step.create_vault_cluster_targets.cluster_name
seal_key_names = step.create_seal_key.resource_names
vpc_id = step.create_vpc.id
}
}
step "create_vault_cluster" {
description = <<-EOF
${global.description.create_vault_cluster} In this instance we'll create a Vault Cluster with
and older version and use Autopilot to upgrade to it.
EOF
module = module.vault_cluster
depends_on = [
step.build_vault,
step.create_vault_cluster_targets
]
providers = {
enos = local.enos_provider[matrix.distro]
}
verifies = [
// verified in modules
quality.vault_artifact_bundle,
quality.vault_artifact_deb,
quality.vault_artifact_rpm,
quality.vault_audit_log,
quality.vault_audit_socket,
quality.vault_audit_syslog,
quality.vault_autojoin_aws,
quality.vault_config_env_variables,
quality.vault_config_file,
quality.vault_config_log_level,
quality.vault_init,
quality.vault_license_required_ent,
quality.vault_service_start,
quality.vault_storage_backend_consul,
quality.vault_storage_backend_raft,
// verified in enos_vault_start resource
quality.vault_api_sys_config_read,
quality.vault_api_sys_ha_status_read,
quality.vault_api_sys_health_read,
quality.vault_api_sys_host_info_read,
quality.vault_api_sys_seal_status_api_read_matches_sys_health,
quality.vault_api_sys_storage_raft_autopilot_configuration_read,
quality.vault_api_sys_storage_raft_autopilot_state_read,
quality.vault_api_sys_storage_raft_configuration_read,
quality.vault_api_sys_replication_status_read,
quality.vault_cli_status_exit_code,
quality.vault_service_systemd_notified,
quality.vault_service_systemd_unit,
]
variables {
cluster_name = step.create_vault_cluster_targets.cluster_name
config_mode = matrix.config_mode
enable_audit_devices = var.vault_enable_audit_devices
install_dir = global.vault_install_dir[matrix.artifact_type]
license = matrix.edition != "ce" ? step.read_license.license : null
packages = concat(global.packages, global.distro_packages[matrix.distro])
release = {
edition = matrix.edition
version = matrix.initial_version
}
seal_attributes = step.create_seal_key.attributes
seal_type = matrix.seal
storage_backend = "raft"
storage_backend_addl_config = {
autopilot_upgrade_version = matrix.initial_version
}
target_hosts = step.create_vault_cluster_targets.hosts
}
}
step "get_local_metadata" {
description = global.description.get_local_metadata
skip_step = matrix.artifact_source != "local"
module = module.get_local_metadata
}
// Wait for our cluster to elect a leader
step "wait_for_leader" {
description = global.description.wait_for_cluster_to_have_leader
module = module.vault_wait_for_leader
depends_on = [step.create_vault_cluster]
providers = {
enos = local.enos_provider[matrix.distro]
}
verifies = [
quality.vault_api_sys_leader_read,
quality.vault_unseal_ha_leader_election,
]
variables {
timeout = 120 # seconds
vault_hosts = step.create_vault_cluster_targets.hosts
vault_install_dir = local.vault_install_dir
vault_root_token = step.create_vault_cluster.root_token
}
}
step "get_vault_cluster_ips" {
description = global.description.get_vault_cluster_ip_addresses
module = module.vault_get_cluster_ips
depends_on = [
step.create_vault_cluster,
step.wait_for_leader,
]
providers = {
enos = local.enos_provider[matrix.distro]
}
verifies = [
quality.vault_api_sys_ha_status_read,
quality.vault_api_sys_leader_read,
quality.vault_cli_operator_members,
]
variables {
vault_hosts = step.create_vault_cluster.target_hosts
vault_install_dir = global.vault_install_dir[matrix.artifact_type]
vault_root_token = step.create_vault_cluster.root_token
}
}
step "verify_write_test_data" {
description = global.description.verify_write_test_data
module = module.vault_verify_write_data
depends_on = [
step.create_vault_cluster,
step.get_vault_cluster_ips
]
providers = {
enos = local.enos_provider[matrix.distro]
}
verifies = [
quality.vault_mount_auth,
quality.vault_mount_kv,
quality.vault_secrets_auth_user_policy_write,
quality.vault_secrets_kv_write,
]
variables {
leader_public_ip = step.get_vault_cluster_ips.leader_public_ip
leader_private_ip = step.get_vault_cluster_ips.leader_private_ip
vault_instances = step.create_vault_cluster.target_hosts
vault_install_dir = global.vault_install_dir[matrix.artifact_type]
vault_root_token = step.create_vault_cluster.root_token
}
}
step "create_autopilot_upgrade_storageconfig" {
description = <<-EOF
An arithmetic module used to dynamically create autopilot storage configuration depending on
whether or not we're testing a local build or a candidate build.
EOF
module = module.autopilot_upgrade_storageconfig
variables {
vault_product_version = matrix.artifact_source == "local" ? step.get_local_metadata.version : var.vault_product_version
}
}
step "upgrade_vault_cluster_with_autopilot" {
module = module.vault_cluster
depends_on = [
step.build_vault,
step.create_vault_cluster,
step.create_autopilot_upgrade_storageconfig,
step.verify_write_test_data
]
providers = {
enos = local.enos_provider[matrix.distro]
}
variables {
artifactory_release = matrix.artifact_source == "artifactory" ? step.build_vault.vault_artifactory_release : null
enable_audit_devices = var.vault_enable_audit_devices
cluster_name = step.create_vault_cluster_targets.cluster_name
config_mode = matrix.config_mode
log_level = var.vault_log_level
force_unseal = matrix.seal == "shamir"
initialize_cluster = false
install_dir = global.vault_install_dir[matrix.artifact_type]
license = matrix.edition != "ce" ? step.read_license.license : null
local_artifact_path = local.artifact_path
manage_service = local.manage_service
packages = concat(global.packages, global.distro_packages[matrix.distro])
root_token = step.create_vault_cluster.root_token
seal_attributes = step.create_seal_key.attributes
seal_type = matrix.seal
shamir_unseal_keys = matrix.seal == "shamir" ? step.create_vault_cluster.unseal_keys_hex : null
storage_backend = "raft"
storage_backend_addl_config = step.create_autopilot_upgrade_storageconfig.storage_addl_config
storage_node_prefix = "upgrade_node"
target_hosts = step.create_vault_cluster_upgrade_targets.hosts
}
}
step "verify_vault_unsealed" {
description = global.description.verify_vault_unsealed
module = module.vault_verify_unsealed
depends_on = [
step.create_vault_cluster,
step.create_vault_cluster_upgrade_targets,
step.upgrade_vault_cluster_with_autopilot,
]
providers = {
enos = local.enos_provider[matrix.distro]
}
verifies = [
quality.vault_auto_unseals_after_autopilot_upgrade,
quality.vault_seal_awskms,
quality.vault_seal_pkcs11,
quality.vault_seal_shamir,
]
variables {
vault_install_dir = global.vault_install_dir[matrix.artifact_type]
vault_instances = step.upgrade_vault_cluster_with_autopilot.target_hosts
}
}
step "verify_raft_auto_join_voter" {
description = global.description.verify_raft_cluster_all_nodes_are_voters
module = module.vault_verify_raft_auto_join_voter
depends_on = [
step.upgrade_vault_cluster_with_autopilot,
step.verify_vault_unsealed
]
providers = {
enos = local.enos_provider[matrix.distro]
}
verifies = quality.vault_raft_voters
variables {
vault_install_dir = global.vault_install_dir[matrix.artifact_type]
vault_instances = step.upgrade_vault_cluster_with_autopilot.target_hosts
vault_root_token = step.upgrade_vault_cluster_with_autopilot.root_token
}
}
step "verify_autopilot_await_server_removal_state" {
description = global.description.verify_autopilot_idle_state
module = module.vault_verify_autopilot
depends_on = [
step.create_vault_cluster_upgrade_targets,
step.upgrade_vault_cluster_with_autopilot,
step.verify_raft_auto_join_voter
]
providers = {
enos = local.enos_provider[matrix.distro]
}
verifies = [
quality.vault_api_sys_storage_raft_autopilot_upgrade_info_read_status_matches,
quality.vault_api_sys_storage_raft_autopilot_upgrade_info_target_version_read_matches_candidate,
]
variables {
vault_autopilot_upgrade_version = matrix.artifact_source == "local" ? step.get_local_metadata.version : var.vault_product_version
vault_autopilot_upgrade_status = "await-server-removal"
vault_install_dir = global.vault_install_dir[matrix.artifact_type]
vault_instances = step.create_vault_cluster.target_hosts
vault_root_token = step.upgrade_vault_cluster_with_autopilot.root_token
}
}
step "wait_for_leader_in_upgrade_targets" {
description = global.description.wait_for_cluster_to_have_leader
module = module.vault_wait_for_leader
depends_on = [
step.create_vault_cluster,
step.create_vault_cluster_upgrade_targets,
step.get_vault_cluster_ips,
step.upgrade_vault_cluster_with_autopilot
]
providers = {
enos = local.enos_provider[matrix.distro]
}
verifies = [
quality.vault_api_sys_leader_read,
quality.vault_autopilot_upgrade_leader_election,
]
variables {
vault_install_dir = global.vault_install_dir[matrix.artifact_type]
vault_root_token = step.create_vault_cluster.root_token
vault_hosts = step.upgrade_vault_cluster_with_autopilot.target_hosts
}
}
step "get_updated_vault_cluster_ips" {
description = global.description.get_vault_cluster_ip_addresses
module = module.vault_get_cluster_ips
depends_on = [
step.create_vault_cluster,
step.create_vault_cluster_upgrade_targets,
step.get_vault_cluster_ips,
step.upgrade_vault_cluster_with_autopilot,
step.wait_for_leader_in_upgrade_targets,
]
providers = {
enos = local.enos_provider[matrix.distro]
}
verifies = [
quality.vault_api_sys_ha_status_read,
quality.vault_api_sys_leader_read,
quality.vault_cli_operator_members,
]
variables {
vault_hosts = step.upgrade_vault_cluster_with_autopilot.target_hosts
vault_install_dir = global.vault_install_dir[matrix.artifact_type]
vault_root_token = step.create_vault_cluster.root_token
}
}
step "verify_read_test_data" {
description = global.description.verify_read_test_data
module = module.vault_verify_read_data
depends_on = [
step.get_updated_vault_cluster_ips,
step.verify_write_test_data,
step.upgrade_vault_cluster_with_autopilot,
step.verify_raft_auto_join_voter
]
providers = {
enos = local.enos_provider[matrix.distro]
}
verifies = quality.vault_secrets_kv_read
variables {
node_public_ips = step.get_updated_vault_cluster_ips.follower_public_ips
vault_instance_count = 6
vault_install_dir = global.vault_install_dir[matrix.artifact_type]
}
}
step "raft_remove_peers" {
description = <<-EOF
Remove the nodes that were running the prior version of Vault from the raft cluster
EOF
module = module.vault_raft_remove_peer
depends_on = [
step.create_vault_cluster_upgrade_targets,
step.get_updated_vault_cluster_ips,
step.upgrade_vault_cluster_with_autopilot,
step.verify_autopilot_await_server_removal_state
]
providers = {
enos = local.enos_provider[matrix.distro]
}
verifies = [
quality.vault_api_sys_storage_raft_remove_peer_write_removes_peer,
quality.vault_cli_operator_raft_remove_peer,
]
variables {
operator_instance = step.get_updated_vault_cluster_ips.leader_public_ip
remove_vault_instances = step.create_vault_cluster.target_hosts
vault_install_dir = global.vault_install_dir[matrix.artifact_type]
vault_instance_count = 3
vault_root_token = step.create_vault_cluster.root_token
}
}
step "remove_old_nodes" {
description = global.description.shutdown_nodes
module = module.shutdown_multiple_nodes
depends_on = [
step.create_vault_cluster,
step.raft_remove_peers
]
providers = {
enos = local.enos_provider[matrix.distro]
}
variables {
old_vault_instances = step.create_vault_cluster.target_hosts
vault_instance_count = 3
}
}
step "verify_autopilot_idle_state" {
description = global.description.verify_autopilot_idle_state
module = module.vault_verify_autopilot
depends_on = [
step.create_vault_cluster_upgrade_targets,
step.upgrade_vault_cluster_with_autopilot,
step.verify_raft_auto_join_voter,
step.remove_old_nodes
]
providers = {
enos = local.enos_provider[matrix.distro]
}
verifies = [
quality.vault_api_sys_storage_raft_autopilot_upgrade_info_read_status_matches,
quality.vault_api_sys_storage_raft_autopilot_upgrade_info_target_version_read_matches_candidate,
]
variables {
vault_autopilot_upgrade_version = matrix.artifact_source == "local" ? step.get_local_metadata.version : var.vault_product_version
vault_autopilot_upgrade_status = "idle"
vault_install_dir = global.vault_install_dir[matrix.artifact_type]
vault_instances = step.upgrade_vault_cluster_with_autopilot.target_hosts
vault_root_token = step.create_vault_cluster.root_token
}
}
step "verify_replication" {
description = global.description.verify_replication_status
module = module.vault_verify_replication
depends_on = [
step.create_vault_cluster_upgrade_targets,
step.upgrade_vault_cluster_with_autopilot,
step.verify_raft_auto_join_voter,
step.remove_old_nodes
]
providers = {
enos = local.enos_provider[matrix.distro]
}
verifies = [
quality.vault_replication_ce_disabled,
quality.vault_replication_ent_dr_available,
quality.vault_replication_ent_pr_available,
]
variables {
vault_edition = matrix.edition
vault_install_dir = global.vault_install_dir[matrix.artifact_type]
vault_instances = step.upgrade_vault_cluster_with_autopilot.target_hosts
}
}
step "verify_vault_version" {
description = global.description.verify_vault_version
module = module.vault_verify_version
depends_on = [
step.create_vault_cluster_upgrade_targets,
step.upgrade_vault_cluster_with_autopilot,
step.verify_raft_auto_join_voter,
step.remove_old_nodes
]
providers = {
enos = local.enos_provider[matrix.distro]
}
verifies = [
quality.vault_version_build_date,
quality.vault_version_edition,
quality.vault_version_release,
]
variables {
vault_instances = step.upgrade_vault_cluster_with_autopilot.target_hosts
vault_edition = matrix.edition
vault_install_dir = global.vault_install_dir[matrix.artifact_type]
vault_product_version = matrix.artifact_source == "local" ? step.get_local_metadata.version : var.vault_product_version
vault_revision = matrix.artifact_source == "local" ? step.get_local_metadata.revision : var.vault_revision
vault_build_date = matrix.artifact_source == "local" ? step.get_local_metadata.build_date : var.vault_build_date
vault_root_token = step.create_vault_cluster.root_token
}
}
step "verify_ui" {
description = global.description.verify_ui
module = module.vault_verify_ui
depends_on = [
step.create_vault_cluster_upgrade_targets,
step.upgrade_vault_cluster_with_autopilot,
step.verify_raft_auto_join_voter,
step.remove_old_nodes
]
providers = {
enos = local.enos_provider[matrix.distro]
}
verifies = quality.vault_ui_assets
variables {
vault_instances = step.upgrade_vault_cluster_with_autopilot.target_hosts
}
}
step "verify_undo_logs_status" {
skip_step = true
# NOTE: temporarily disable undo logs checking until it is fixed. See VAULT-20259
# skip_step = semverconstraint(var.vault_product_version, "<1.13.0-0")
module = module.vault_verify_undo_logs
description = <<-EOF
Verifies that undo logs is correctly enabled on newly upgraded target hosts. For this it will
query the metrics system backend for the vault.core.replication.write_undo_logs gauge.
EOF
depends_on = [
step.create_vault_cluster_upgrade_targets,
step.remove_old_nodes,
step.upgrade_vault_cluster_with_autopilot,
step.verify_autopilot_idle_state
]
verifies = quality.vault_api_sys_metrics_vault_core_replication_write_undo_logs_enabled
providers = {
enos = local.enos_provider[matrix.distro]
}
variables {
vault_install_dir = global.vault_install_dir[matrix.artifact_type]
vault_instances = step.upgrade_vault_cluster_with_autopilot.target_hosts
vault_root_token = step.create_vault_cluster.root_token
}
}
# Verify that upgrading from a version <1.16.0 does not introduce Default LCQ
step "verify_default_lcq" {
description = <<-EOF
Verify that the default max lease count is 300,000 when the upgraded nodes are running
Vault >= 1.16.0.
EOF
module = module.vault_verify_default_lcq
depends_on = [
step.create_vault_cluster_upgrade_targets,
step.remove_old_nodes,
step.upgrade_vault_cluster_with_autopilot,
step.verify_autopilot_idle_state
]
verifies = quality.vault_api_sys_quotas_lease_count_read_max_leases_default
providers = {
enos = local.enos_provider[matrix.distro]
}
variables {
vault_instances = step.upgrade_vault_cluster_with_autopilot.target_hosts
vault_root_token = step.create_vault_cluster.root_token
vault_autopilot_default_max_leases = local.vault_autopilot_default_max_leases
}
}
output "audit_device_file_path" {
description = "The file path for the file audit device, if enabled"
value = step.create_vault_cluster.audit_device_file_path
}
output "cluster_name" {
description = "The Vault cluster name"
value = step.create_vault_cluster.cluster_name
}
output "hosts" {
description = "The Vault cluster target hosts"
value = step.create_vault_cluster.target_hosts
}
output "private_ips" {
description = "The Vault cluster private IPs"
value = step.create_vault_cluster.private_ips
}
output "public_ips" {
description = "The Vault cluster public IPs"
value = step.create_vault_cluster.public_ips
}
output "root_token" {
description = "The Vault cluster root token"
value = step.create_vault_cluster.root_token
}
output "recovery_key_shares" {
description = "The Vault cluster recovery key shares"
value = step.create_vault_cluster.recovery_key_shares
}
output "recovery_keys_b64" {
description = "The Vault cluster recovery keys b64"
value = step.create_vault_cluster.recovery_keys_b64
}
output "recovery_keys_hex" {
description = "The Vault cluster recovery keys hex"
value = step.create_vault_cluster.recovery_keys_hex
}
output "seal_attributes" {
description = "The Vault cluster seal attributes"
value = step.create_seal_key.attributes
}
output "unseal_keys_b64" {
description = "The Vault cluster unseal keys"
value = step.create_vault_cluster.unseal_keys_b64
}
output "unseal_keys_hex" {
description = "The Vault cluster unseal keys hex"
value = step.create_vault_cluster.unseal_keys_hex
}
output "upgrade_hosts" {
description = "The Vault cluster target hosts"
value = step.upgrade_vault_cluster_with_autopilot.target_hosts
}
output "upgrade_private_ips" {
description = "The Vault cluster private IPs"
value = step.upgrade_vault_cluster_with_autopilot.private_ips
}
output "upgrade_public_ips" {
description = "The Vault cluster public IPs"
value = step.upgrade_vault_cluster_with_autopilot.public_ips
}
}