As the Vault pipeline and release processes evolve over time, so too must the tooling that drives them. Historically we've utilized a combination of CI features and shell scripts that are wrapped into make targets to drive our CI. While this
approach has worked, it requires careful consideration of what features to use (bash in CI almost never matches bash in developer machines, etc.) and often requires a deep understanding of several CLI tools (jq, etc). `make` itself also has limitations in user experience, e.g. passing flags.
As we're all in on Github Actions as our pipeline coordinator, continuing to utilize and build CLI tools to perform our pipeline tasks makes sense. This PR adds a new CLI tool called `pipeline` which we can use to build new isolated tasks that we can string together in Github Actions. We intend to use this utility as the interface for future release automation work, see VAULT-27514.
For the first task in this new `pipeline` tool, I've chosen to build two small sub-commands:
* `pipeline releases list-versions` - Allows us to list Vault versions between a range. The range is configurable either by setting `--upper` and/or `--lower` bounds, or by using the `--nminus` to set the N-X to go back from the current branches version. As CE and ENT do not have version parity we also consider the `--edition`, as well as none-to-many `--skip` flags to exclude specific versions.
* `pipeline generate enos-dynamic-config` - Which creates dynamic enos configuration based on the branch and the current list of release versions. It takes largely the same flags as the `release list-versions` command, however it also expects a `--dir` for the enos directory and a `--file` where the dynamic configuration will be written. This allows us to dynamically update and feed the latest versions into our sampling algorithm to get coverage over all supported prior versions.
We then integrate these new tools into the pipeline itself and cache the dynamic config on a weekly basis. We also cache the pipeline tool itself as it will likely become a repository for pipeline specific tooling. The caching strategy for the `pipeline` tool itself will make most workflows that require it super fast.
Signed-off-by: Ryan Cragun <me@ryan.ec>
Context
-------
Building and testing Vault artifacts on pull requests and merges is
responsible for about 1/3rd of our overall spend on Vault CI. Of the
artifacts that we ship as part of a release, we do Enos testing scenarios
on the `linux/amd64` and `linux/arm64` binaries and their derivative
artifacts. The extended build artifacts for non-Linux platforms or less
common machine architectures are not tested at this time. They are built,
notarized, and signed as part of every pull request update and merge. As
we don't actually test these artifacts, the only gain we get from this
rather expensive behavior is that we wont merge a change that would prevent
Vault from building on one of the extended targets. Extended platform or
architecture changes are quite rare, so performing this work as frequently
as we do is costly in both monetary and developer time for little relative
safety benefit.
Goals
-----
Rethink and implement how and when we build binaries and artifacts of Vault
so that we can spend less money on repetitive work and while also reducing
the time it takes for the build and test pipelines to complete.
Solution
--------
Instead of building all release artifacts on every push, we'll opt to build
only our testable (core) artifacts. With this change we are introducing a
bit of risk. We could merge a change that breaks an extended platform and
only find out after the fact when we trigger a complete build for a release.
We'll hedge against that risk by building all of the release targets on a
scheduled cadence to ensure that they are still buildable.
We'll make building all of the targets optional on any pull request by
use of a `build/all` label on the pull request.
Further considerations
----------------------
* We want to reduce the total number of workflows and runners for all of our
pipelines if possible. As each workflow runner has infrastructure cost and
runner time penalties, using a single runner over many is often preferred.
* Many of our jobs runners have been optimized for cost and performance. We
should simplify the choices of which runners to use.
* CRT requires us to use the same build workflow in both CE and Ent.
Historically that meant that modifying `build.yml` in CE would result in a
merge conflict with `build.yml` in Ent, and break our merge workflows.
* Workflow flow control in both `build.yml` and `ci.yml` can be quite
complicated, as each needs to maintain compatibility whether executed as CE
or Ent, and when triggered with various Github events like pull_request,
push, and workflow_call, each with their own requirements.
* Many jobs utilize similar patterns of flow control and metadata but are not
reusable.
* Workflow call depth has a maximum of four, so we need to be quite
considerate when calling other workflows.
* Called workflows can only have 10 inputs.
Implementation
--------------
* Refactor the `build.yml` workflow to be agnostic to whether or not it is
executing in CE or Ent. That makes future updates to the build much easier
as we won't have to worry about merge conflicts when the change is merged
downstream.
* Extract common steps in workflows into composite actions that we can reuse.
* Fix bugs where some but not all workflows would use different Git
references when building and testing a pull request.
* We rewrite the application, docs, and UI change helpers as a composite
action. This allows us to re-use this logic to make consistent behavior
choices across build and CI.
* We combine several `build.yml` and `ci.yml` jobs into our final job.
This reduces the number of workflows required for the same behavior while
saving time overall.
* Update most of our action pins.
Results
-------
| Metric | Before | After | Diff |
|-------------------|----------|---------|-------|
| Duration: | ~14-18m | ~15-18m | ~ = |
| Workflows: | 43 | 18 | - 58% |
| Billable time: | ~1h15m | 16m | - 79% |
| Saved artifacts: | 34 | 12 | - 65% |
Infra costs should map closely to billable time.
Network I/O costs should map closely to the workflow count.
Storage costs should map directly with saved artifacts.
We could probably get parity with duration by getting more clever with
our UBI container build, as that's where we're seeing the increase. I'm
not yet concerned as it takes roughly the same time for this job to
complete as it did before.
While the CI workflow was not the focus on the PR, some shared
refactoring does show some marginal improvements there.
| Metric | Before | After | Diff |
|-------------------|----------|----------|--------|
| Duration: | ~24m | ~12.75m | - 15% |
| Workflows: | 55 | 47 | - 8% |
| Billable time: | ~4h20m | ~3h36m | - 7% |
Further focus on streamlining the CI workflows would likely result in a
few more marginal improvements, but nothing on the order like we've seen
with the build workflow.
Signed-off-by: Ryan Cragun <me@ryan.ec>
We're on a quest to reduce our pipeline execution time to both enhance
our developer productivity but also to reduce the overall cost of the CI
pipeline. The strategy we use here reduces workflow execution time and
network I/O cost by reducing our module cache size and using binary
external tools when possible. We no longer download modules and build
many of the external tools thousands of times a day.
Our previous process of installing internal and external developer tools
was scattered and inconsistent. Some tools were installed via `go
generate -tags tools ./tools/...`,
others via various `make` targets, and some only in Github Actions
workflows. This process led to some undesirable side effects:
* The modules of some dev and test tools were included with those
of the Vault project. This leads to us having to manage our own
Go modules with those of external tools. Prior to Go 1.16 this
was the recommended way to handle external tools, but now
`go install tool@version` is the recommended way to handle
external tools that need to be build from source as it supports
specific versions but does not modify the go.mod.
* Due to Github cache constraints we combine our build and test Go
module caches together, but having our developer tools as deps in
our module results in a larger cache which is downloaded on every
build and test workflow runner. Removing the external tools that were
included in our go.mod reduced the expanded module cache by size
by ~300MB, thus saving time and network I/O costs when downloading
the module cache.
* Not all of our developer tools were included in our modules. Some were
being installed with `go install` or `go run`, so they didn't take
advantage of a single module cache. This resulted in us downloading
Go modules on every CI and Build runner in order to build our
external tools.
* Building our developer tools from source in CI is slow. Where possible
we can prefer to use pre-built binaries in CI workflows. No more
module download or tool compiles if we can avoid them.
I've refactored how we define internal and external build tools
in our Makefile and added several new targets to handle both building
the developer tools locally for development and verifying that they are
available. This allows for an easy developer bootstrap while also
supporting installation of many of the external developer tools from
pre-build binaries in CI. This reduces our network IO and run time
across nearly all of our actions runners.
While working on this I caught and resolved a few unrelated issue:
* Both our Go and Proto format checks we're being run incorrectly. In
CI they we're writing changes but not failing if changes were
detected. The Go was less of a problem as we have git hooks that
are intended to enforce formatting, however we drifted over time.
* Our Git hooks couldn't handle removing a Go file without failing. I
moved the diff check into the new Go helper and updated it to handle
removing files.
* I combined a few separate scripts and into helpers and added a few
new capabilities.
* I refactored how we install Go modules to make it easier to download
and tidy all of the projects go.mod's.
* Refactor our internal and external tool installation and verification
into a tools.sh helper.
* Combined more complex Go verification into `scripts/go-helper.sh` and
utilize it in the `Makefile` and git commit hooks.
* Add `Makefile` targets for executing our various tools.sh helpers.
* Update our existing `make` targets to use new tool targets.
* Normalize our various scripts and targets output to have a consistent
output format.
* In CI, install many of our external dependencies as binaries wherever
possible. When not possible we'll build them from scratch but not mess
with the shared module cache.
* [QT-641] Remove our external build tools from our project Go modules.
* [QT-641] Remove extraneous `go list`'s from our `set-up-to` composite
action.
* Fix formatting and regen our protos
Signed-off-by: Ryan Cragun <me@ryan.ec>
This causes the registry to now contain ent plugins on ent; previously it did not, though that appears to have been the intention. I believe this is because of the order in which inits were run.
Having changed this, various tests broke that were relying on the incorrect behaviour. Several tests were changed to rely less on opaque counts of expected plugins, instead they're now using explicit comparison by name.
Replace our prior implementation of Enos test groups with the new Enos
sampling feature. With this feature we're able to describe which
scenarios and variant combinations are valid for a given artifact and
allow enos to create a valid sample field (a matrix of all compatible
scenarios) and take an observation (select some to run) for us. This
ensures that every valid scenario and variant combination will
now be a candidate for testing in the pipeline. See QT-504[0] for further
details on the Enos sampling capabilities.
Our prior implementation only tested the amd64 and arm64 zip artifacts,
as well as the Docker container. We now include the following new artifacts
in the test matrix:
* CE Amd64 Debian package
* CE Amd64 RPM package
* CE Arm64 Debian package
* CE Arm64 RPM package
Each artifact includes a sample definition for both pre-merge/post-merge
(build) and release testing.
Changes:
* Remove the hand crafted `enos-run-matrices` ci matrix targets and replace
them with per-artifact samples.
* Use enos sampling to generate different sample groups on all pull
requests.
* Update the enos scenario matrices to handle HSM and FIPS packages.
* Simplify enos scenarios by using shared globals instead of
cargo-culted locals.
Note: This will require coordination with vault-enterprise to ensure a
smooth migration to the new system. Integrating new scenarios or
modifying existing scenarios/variants should be much smoother after this
initial migration.
[0] https://github.com/hashicorp/enos/pull/102
Signed-off-by: Ryan Cragun <me@ryan.ec>
* adding new version bump refactoring
* address comments
* remove changes used for testing
* add the version bump event!
* fix local enos scenarios
* remove unnecessary local get_local_metadata steps from scenarios
* add version base, pre, and meta to the get_local_metadata module
* use the get_local_metadata module in the local builder for version
metadata
* update the version verifier to always require a build date
Signed-off-by: Ryan Cragun <me@ryan.ec>
* Update to embed the base version from the VERSION file directly into version.go.
This ensures that any go tests can use the same (valid) version as CI and so can local builds and local enos runs.
We still want to be able to set a default metadata value in version_base.go as this is not something that we set in the VERSION file - we pass this in as an ldflag in CI (matters more for ENT but we want to keep these files in sync across repos).
* update comment
* fixing bad merge
* removing actions-go-build as it won't work with the latest go caching changes
* fix logic for getting version in enos-lint.yml
* fix version number
* removing unneeded module
---------
Signed-off-by: Ryan Cragun <me@ryan.ec>
Co-authored-by: Claire <claire@hashicorp.com>
Co-authored-by: Ryan Cragun <me@ryan.ec>
* Adding explicit MPL license for sub-package.
This directory and its subdirectories (packages) contain files licensed with the MPLv2 `LICENSE` file in this directory and are intentionally licensed separately from the BSL `LICENSE` file at the root of this repository.
* Adding explicit MPL license for sub-package.
This directory and its subdirectories (packages) contain files licensed with the MPLv2 `LICENSE` file in this directory and are intentionally licensed separately from the BSL `LICENSE` file at the root of this repository.
* Updating the license from MPL to Business Source License.
Going forward, this project will be licensed under the Business Source License v1.1. Please see our blog post for more details at https://hashi.co/bsl-blog, FAQ at www.hashicorp.com/licensing-faq, and details of the license at www.hashicorp.com/bsl.
* add missing license headers
* Update copyright file headers to BUS-1.1
* Fix test that expected exact offset on hcl file
---------
Co-authored-by: hashicorp-copywrite[bot] <110428419+hashicorp-copywrite[bot]@users.noreply.github.com>
Co-authored-by: Sarah Thompson <sthompson@hashicorp.com>
Co-authored-by: Brian Kassouf <bkassouf@hashicorp.com>
* fix multiline
* shellcheck, and success message for builds
* add full path
* cat the summary
* fix and faster
* fix if condition
* base64 in a separate step
* echo
* check against empty string
* add echo
* only use matrix ids
* only id
* echo matrix
* remove wrapping array
* tojson
* try echo again
* use jq to get packages
* don't quote
* only run binary tests once
* only run binary tests once
* test what's wrong with the binary
* separate file
* use matrix file
* failed test
* update comment on success
* correct variable name
* bae64 fix
* output to file
* use multiline
* fix
* fix formatting
* fix newline
* fix whitespace
* correct body, remove comma
* small fixes
* shellcheck
* another shellcheck fix
* fix deprecation checker
* only run comments for prs
* Update .github/workflows/test-go.yml
Co-authored-by: Mike Palmiotto <mike.palmiotto@hashicorp.com>
* Update .github/workflows/test-go.yml
Co-authored-by: Mike Palmiotto <mike.palmiotto@hashicorp.com>
* fixes
---------
Co-authored-by: Mike Palmiotto <mike.palmiotto@hashicorp.com>
* Add backend format linting to pre-commit hook
By taking a slight penalty with each commit, we can ensure that
contributors follow the format behavior by default (if they run hooks),
making accidental PRs without proper formatting less likely.
Additionally, fix gofmtcheck to align with the Makefile, fixing the
corresponding fmtcheck target for use with the hook.
Signed-off-by: Alexander Scheel <alex.scheel@hashicorp.com>
* Fix formatting errors
Signed-off-by: Alexander Scheel <alex.scheel@hashicorp.com>
---------
Signed-off-by: Alexander Scheel <alex.scheel@hashicorp.com>
Add a go:generate helper called stubmaker, which generates appropriate stubs on ent based on oss stubs, but only when needed (i.e. real ent funcs haven't been added yet.)
* combine into one checker
* combine and simplify ci checks
* add to test package list
* remove testing test
* only run deprecations check
* only run deprecations check
* remove unneeded repo check
* fix bash options
1) Reduce sleep time - in my experience, 1 second is plenty for a dev
Vault to start up its HTTP listener - having the user wait for
5 seconds seems excessive.
2) Comment reason for both sleeps.
3) Remove line of code that is obsolete, now the Enterprise transition
from stored to autoloaded licenses has completed.
By reversing the logic and adding a `REMOVE_SYMBOLS` environment
variable that, when set, will remove symbols.
This has been requested to re-enable Dynatrace support, which
requires symbols are intact.
Sadly this increases the size (on my mac) from 192,609,682 bytes
to 236,696,722 bytes (+23% increase).
I confirmed that this adds symbols back, and that `dlv` will load
the Vault binary.
* Add Helios Design System Components (#19278)
* adds hds dependency
* updates reset import path
* sets minifyCSS advanced option to false
* Remove node-sass (#19376)
* removes node-sass and fixes sass compilation
* fixes active tab li class
* Sidebar Navigation Components (#19446)
* links ember-shared-components addon and imports styles
* adds sidebar frame and nav components
* updates HcNav component name to HcAppFrame and adds sidebar UserMenu component
* adds tests for sidebar components
* fixes tests
* updates user menu styling
* fixes typos in nav cluster component
* changes padding value in sidebar stylesheet to use variable
* Replace and remove old nav components with new ones (#19447)
* links ember-shared-components addon and imports styles
* adds sidebar frame and nav components
* updates activeCluster on auth service and adds activeSession prop for sidebar visibility
* replaces old nav components with new ones in templates
* fixes sidebar visibility issue and updates user menu label class
* removes NavHeader usage
* adds clients index route to redirect to dashboard
* removes unused HcAppFrame footer block and reduces page header top margin
* Nav component cleanup (#19681)
* removes nav-header components
* removes navbar styling
* removes status-menu component and styles
* removes cluster and auth info components
* removes menu-sidebar component and styling
* fixes tests
* Console Panel Updates (#19741)
* updates console panel styling
* adds test for opening and closing the console panel
* updates console panel background color to use hds token
* adds right margin to console panel input
* updates link-status banner styling
* updates hc nav components to new API
* Namespace Picker Updates (#19753)
* updates namespace-picker
* updates namespace picker menu styling
* adds bottom margin to env banner
* updates class order on namespace picker link
* restores manage namespaces refresh icon
* removes manage namespaces nav icon
* removes home link component (#20027)
* Auth and Error View Updates (#19749)
* adds vault logo to auth page
* updates top level error template
* updates loading substate handling and moves policies link from access to cluster nav (#20033)
* moves console panel to bottom of viewport (#20183)
* HDS Sidebar Nav Components (#20197)
* updates nav components to hds
* upgrades project yarn version to 3.5
* fixes issues in app frame component
* updates sidenav actions to use icon button component
* Sidebar navigation acceptance tests (#20270)
* adds sidebar navigation acceptance tests and fixes other test failures
* console panel styling tweaks
* bumps addon version
* remove and ignore yarn install-state file
* fixes auth service and console tests
* moves classes from deleted files after bulma merge
* fixes sass syntax errors blocking build
* cleans up dart sass deprecation warnings
* adds changelog entry
* hides namespace picker when sidebar nav panel is minimized
* style tweaks
* fixes sidebar nav tests
* bumps hds addon to latest version and removes style override
* updates modify-passthrough-response helper
* updates sidebar nav tests
* mfa-setup test fix attempt
* fixes cluster mfa setup test
* remove deprecated yarn ignore-optional flag from makefile
* removes another instance of yarn ignore-optional and updates ui readme
* removes unsupported yarn verbose flag from ci-helper
* hides nav headings when user does not have access to any sub links
* removes unused optional deps and moves lint-staged to dev deps
* updates has-permission helper and permissions service tests
* fixes issue with console panel not filling container width
* cleans up dependencies with critical warnigns
* adds changelog entry
* updates dockerfiles and ci github workflow to use node 16
* removes ui gh workflow not being used
* deprecation check
* adding script
* add execute permission to script
* revert changes
* adding the script back
* added working script for local and GHA
* give execute permissions
* updating revgrep
* adding changes to script, tools
* run go mod tidy
* removing default ref
* make bootstrap
* adding to makefile
Introducing a new approach to testing Vault artifacts before merge
and after merge/notorization/signing. Rather than run a few static
scenarios across the artifacts, we now have the ability to run a
pseudo random sample of scenarios across many different build artifacts.
We've added 20 possible scenarios for the AMD64 and ARM64 binary
bundles, which we've broken into five test groups. On any given push to
a pull request branch, we will now choose a random test group and
execute its corresponding scenarios against the resulting build
artifacts. This gives us greater test coverage but lets us split the
verification across many different pull requests.
The post-merge release testing pipeline behaves in a similar fashion,
however, the artifacts that we use for testing have been notarized and
signed prior to testing. We've also reduce the number of groups so that
we run more scenarios after merge to a release branch.
We intend to take what we've learned building this in Github Actions and
roll it into an easier to use feature that is native to Enos. Until then,
we'll have to manually add scenarios to each matrix file and manually
number the test group. It's important to note that Github requires every
matrix to include at least one vector, so every artifact that is being
tested must include a single scenario in order for all workflows to pass
and thus satisfy branch merge requirements.
* Add support for different artifact types to enos-run
* Add support for different runner type to enos-run
* Add arm64 scenarios to build matrix
* Expand build matrices to include different variants
* Update Consul versions in Enos scenarios and matrices
* Refactor enos-run environment
* Add minimum version filtering support to enos-run. This allows us to
automatically exclude scenarios that require a more recent version of
Vault
* Add maximum version filtering support to enos-run. This allows us to
automatically exclude scenarios that require an older version of
Vault
* Fix Node 12 deprecation warnings
* Rename enos-verify-stable to enos-release-testing-oss
* Convert artifactory matrix into enos-release-testing-oss matrices
* Add all Vault editions to Enos scenario matrices
* Fix verify version with complex Vault edition metadata
* Rename the crt-builder to ci-helper
* Add more version helpers to ci-helper and Makefile
* Update CODEOWNERS for quality team
* Add support for filtering matrices by group and version constraints
* Add support for pseudo random test scenario execution
Signed-off-by: Ryan Cragun <me@ryan.ec>
Move version out of SDK. For now it's a copy rather than move: the part not addressed by this change is sdk/helper/useragent.String, which we'll want to remove in favour of PluginString. That will have to wait until we've removed uses of useragent.String from all builtins.
Here we make the following major changes:
* Centralize CRT builder logic into a script utility so that we can share the
logic for building artifacts in CI or locally.
* Simplify the build workflow by calling a reusable workflow many times
instead of repeating the contents.
* Create a workflow that validates whether or not the build workflow and all
child workflows have succeeded to allow for merge protection.
Motivation
* We need branch requirements for the build workflow and all subsequent
integration tests (QT-353)
* We need to ensure that the Enos local builder works (QT-558)
* Debugging build failures can be difficult because one has to hand craft the
steps to recreate the build
* Merge conflicts between Vault OSS and Vault ENT build workflows are quite
painful. As the build workflow must be the same file and name we'll reduce
what is contained in each that is unique. Implementations of building
will be unique per edition so we don't have to worry about conflict
resolution.
* Since we're going to be touching the build workflow to do the first two
items we might as well try and improve those other issues at the same time
to reduce the overhead of backports and conflicts.
Considerations
* Build logic for Vault OSS and Vault ENT differs
* The Enos local builder was duplicating a lot of what we did in the CRT build
workflow
* Version and other artifact metadata has been an issue before. Debugging it
has been tedious and error prone.
* The build workflow is full of brittle copy and paste that is hard to
understand, especially for all of the release editions in Vault Enterprise
* Branch check requirements for workflows are incredibly painful to use for
workflows that are dynamic or change often. The required workflows have to be
configured in Github settings by administrators. They would also prevent us
from having simple docs PRs since required integration workflows always have
to run to satisfy branch requirements.
* Doormat credentials requirements that are coming will require us to modify
which event types trigger workflows. This changes those ahead of time since
we're doing so much to build workflow. The only noticeable impact will be
that the build workflow no longer runs on pushes to non-main or release
branches. In order to test other branches it requires a workflow_dispatch
from the Actions tab or a pull request.
Solutions
* Centralize the logic that determines build metadata and creates releasable
Vault artifacts. Instead of cargo-culting logic multiple times in the build
workflow and the Enos local modules, we now have a crt-builder script which
determines build metadata and also handles building the UI, Vault, and the
package bundle. There are make targets for all of the available sub-commands.
Now what we use in the pipeline is the same thing as the local builder, and
it can be executed locally by developers. The crt-builder script works in OSS
and Enterprise so we will never have to deal with them being divergent or with
special casing things in the build workflow.
* Refactor the bulk of the Vault building into a reusable workflow that we can
call multiple times. This allows us to define Vault builds in a much simpler
manner and makes resolving merge conflicts much easier.
* Rather than trying to maintain a list and manually configure the branch check
requirements for build, we'll trigger a single workflow that uses the github
event system to determine if the build workflow (all of the sub-workflows
included) have passed. We'll then create branch restrictions on that single
workflow down the line.
Signed-off-by: Ryan Cragun me@ryan.ec
* Update go version to 1.19.2
This commit updates the default version of go to 1.19.2. This update
includes minor security fixes for archive/tar, net/http/httputil, and
regexp packages.
For more information on the release, see: https://go.dev/doc/devel/release#go1.19.2
* Update Docker versions in CI to 20.10.17
After updating Vault to go version 1.19.2, there were several SIGABRTs
in the vault tests. These were related to a missing `pthread_create`
syscall in Docker. Since CI was using a much older version of Docker,
the fix was to bump it to latest-1 (20.10.17).
While we're at it, add a note in the developer docs encouraging the use
of the latest Docker version.
Update Go to 1.18
From 1.17.12
1.18.5 was just released, but not all packages have been updated, so I
went with 1.18.4
Co-authored-by: Steven Clark <steven.clark@hashicorp.com>
Remove gox in favor of go build.
`gox` hasn't had a release to update it in many years, so is missing
support for many modern systems, like `darwin/arm64`.
In any case, we only use it for dev builds, where we don't even use
the ability of it to build for multiple platforms. Release builds use
`go build` now.
So, this switches to `go build` everywhere.
I pulled this down and tested it in Windows as well. (Side note: I
couldn't get `gox` to work in Windows, so couldn't build before this
change.)
