These ones replace the previous conn_get_{from,to}_addr() used to wait
for the connection establishment before sending a LOCAL line. The
error handling was preserved.
In the function stream_int_notify(), when the opposite stream-interface is
blocked because there is no more room into the input buffer, if the flag
CF_WRITE_PARTIAL is set on this buffer, it is unblocked. It is a way to unblock
the reads on the other side because some data was sent.
But it is a problem during the fast-forwarding because only the stream is able
to remove the flag CF_WRITE_PARTIAL. So it is possible to have this flag because
of a previous send while the input buffer of the opposite stream-interface is
now full. In such case, the opposite stream-interface will be woken up for
nothing because its input buffer is full. If the same happens on the opposite
side, we will have a loop consumming all the CPU.
To fix the bug, the opposite side is now only notify if there is some available
room in its input buffer in the function si_cs_send(), so only if some data was
sent.
This patch must be backported to 2.0 and 1.9.
In the function si_cs_send(), what is done when an error occurred on the
connection or the conn_stream or when some successfully data was send via a pipe
or the channel's buffer may be factorized at the function. It slightly simplify
the function.
This patch must be backported to 2.0 and 1.9 because a bugfix depends on it.
Only add SI_FL_ERR if the stream_interface is connected, or is attempting
a connection. We may get there because the stream_interface's tasklet
was woken up, but before it actually runs, process_stream() may be called,
detect that there were an error, and change the state of the stream_interface
to SI_ST_TAR. When the stream_interface's tasklet then run, the connection
may still have CO_FL_ERROR, but that error was already accounted for, so
just ignore it.
This should be backported to 2.0.
It's really confusing to call it a task because it's a tasklet and used
in places where tasks and tasklets are used together. Let's rename it
to tasklet to remove this confusion.
In si_cs_recv(), if we got the CS_FL_EOI flag on the conn_stream, make sure
we return 1, so that si_cs_process() will be called, and wake
process_stream() up, otherwise if we're unlucky the flag will never be
noticed, and the stream won't be woken up.
The "goto redo" at the end of process_stream() to make the states converge
is still a big source of problems and mostly stems from the very late call
to the send() functions, whose results need to be considered, while it's
being done in si_update_both() when leaving.
This patch extracts the si_sync_send() calls from si_update_both(), and
places them at the relevant places in process_stream(), which are just
after the amount of data to forward is updated and before the shutw()
calls (which were also moved). The stream-interface resynchronization
needs to go slightly upper to take into account the transition from CON
to RDY that will happen consecutive to some successful send(), and that's
all.
By doing so we can now get rid of this loop and have si_update_both()
called only to update the stream interface and channel when leaving the
function, as it was initially designed to work.
It is worth noting that a number of the remaining conditions to perform
a goto resync_XXX still seem suboptimal and would benefit from being
refined to perform les resynchronization. But what matters at this stage
is that the code remains valid and efficient.
Just like we have a synchronous recv() function for the stream interface,
let's have a synchronous send function that we'll be able to call from
different places. For now this only moves the code, nothing more.
We should not update the two directions at once, in fact we should update
the Rx path after recv() and the Tx path after send(). Let's start by
splitting the update function in two for this.
Now whenever an I/O event succeeds during a connection attempt, we
switch the stream-int's state to SI_ST_RDY. This allows si_update()
to update R/W timeouts on the channel and end points to start to
consume outgoing data and to subscribe to lower layers in case of
failure. It also allows chk_rcv() to be performed on the other side
to enable data forwarding and make sure we don't fall into a situation
where no more events happen and nothing moves anymore.
The main reason for all the trouble we're facing with stream interface
error or timeout reports during the connection phase is that we currently
can't make the difference between a connection attempt and a validated
connection attempt. It is problematic because we tend to switch early
to SI_ST_EST but can't always do what we want in this state since it's
supposed to be set when we don't need to visit sess_establish() again.
This patch introduces a new state betwen SI_ST_CON and SI_ST_EST, which
is SI_ST_RDY. It indicates that we've verified that the connection is
ready. It's a transient state, like SI_ST_DIS, that cannot persist when
leaving process_stream(). For now it is not set, only verified in various
tests where SI_ST_CON was used or SI_ST_EST depending on the cases.
The stream-int state diagram was minimally updated to reflect the new
state, though it is largely obsolete and would need to be seriously
updated.
The stream interface state checks involving ranges were replaced with
checks on a set of states, already revealing some issues. No issue was
fixed, all was replaced in a one-to-one mapping for easier control. Some
checks involving a strict difference were also replaced with fields to
be clearer. At this stage, the result must be strictly equivalent. A few
tests were also turned to their bit-field equivalent for better readability
or in preparation for upcoming changes.
The test performed in the SPOE filter was swapped so that the closed and
error states are evicted first and that the established vs conn state is
tested second.
Now that the various handshakes come with their own XPRT, there's no
need for the CONN_FL_SOCK* flags, and the conn_sock_want|stop functions,
so garbage-collect them.
Connection handshakes were rarely stacked on top of each other, but the
recent experiments consisting in sending PROXY over SOCKS4 revealed a
number of issues in these lower layers. First, each handler waiting for
data MUST subscribe to recv events with __conn_sock_want_recv() and MUST
unsubscribe from send events using __conn_sock_stop_send() to avoid any
wake-up loop in case a previous sender has set this. Second, each handler
waiting for sending MUST subscribe to send events with __conn_sock_want_send()
and MUST unsubscribe from recv events using __conn_sock_stop_recv() to
avoid any wake-up loop in case some data are available on the connection.
Till now this was done at various random places, and in particular the
cases where the FD was not ready for recv forgot to re-enable reading.
Second, while senders can happily use conn_sock_send() which automatically
handles EINTR, loops, and marks the FD as not ready with fd_cant_send(),
there is no equivalent for recv so receivers facing EAGAIN MUST call
fd_cant_send() to enable polling. It could be argued that implementing
an equivalent conn_sock_recv() function could be useful and more
long-term proof than the current situation.
Third, both types of handlers MUST unsubscribe from their respective
events once they managed to do their job, and none may even play with
__conn_xprt_*(). Here again this was lacking, and one surprizing call
to __conn_xprt_stop_recv() was present in the proxy protocol parser
for TCP6 messages!
Thanks to Alexander Liu for his help on this issue.
This patch must be backported to 1.9 and possibly some older versions,
though the SOCKS parts should be dropped.
In conn_si_send_proxy(), if we don't have a conn_stream yet, because the mux
won't be created until the SSL handshake is done, retrieve the opposite's
connection from the session. At this point, we know the session associated
with the connection is the one that initiated it, and we can thus just use
the session's origin.
This should be backported to 1.9.
Because the channel_recv_max() always return the right value, for HTX and legacy
streams, we don't need to set this flag. The multiplexer don't use it anymore.
Now, we only return the start-line. If not found, NULL is returned. No lookup is
performed and the HTX message is no more updated. It is now the caller
responsibility to update the position of the start-line to the right value. So
when it is not found, i.e sl_pos is set to -1, it means the last start-line has
been already processed and the next one has not been inserted yet.
It is mandatory to rely on this kind of warranty to store 1xx informational
responses and final reponse in the same HTX message.
When a parsing error occurrs in the H1 multiplexer, we stop to copy HTX
blocks. So the error may be reported with an emtpy HTX message. For instance, if
the headers parsing failed. When it happens, the flag CS_FL_EOS is also set on
the conn_stream. But it is an error. Most of time, it is set on established
connections, so it is not really an issue. But if it happens when the server
connection is not fully established, the connection is shut down immediatly and
the stream-interface is switched from SI_ST_CON to SI_ST_DIS/CLO. So HTX
analyzers have no chance to catch the error.
Instead of setting CS_FL_EOS, it is fairly better to set CS_FL_EOI, which is the
right flag to use. The same is also done on H2 upgrade. As a side effet of this
fix, in the stream-interface code, we must now set the flag CF_READ_PARTIAL on
the channel when the flag CF_EOI is set. It is a warranty to wakeup the stream
when EOI is reported to the channel while no data are received.
This patch must be backported to 1.9.
When we receive a read0, and we're still in SI_ST_CON state (so on an
outgoing conneciton), don't immediately switch to SI_ST_DIS, or, we would
never call sess_establish(), and so the analysers will never run.
Instead, let sess_establish() handle that case, and switch to SI_ST_DIS if
we already have CF_SHUTR on the channel.
This should be backported to 1.9.
In si_cs_send(), don't check CF_EOI on the request channel to decide if the
request is complete and if we should save the buffer to eventually attempt
L7 retries. The flag may not be set yet, and it may too be set to early,
before we're done modifying the buffer. Instead, get the msg, and make sure
its state is HTTP_MSG_DONE.
That way we will store the request buffer when sending it even in H2.
When running in HTX mode, if we sent the request, but failed to get the
answer, either because the server just closed its socket, we hit a server
timeout, or we get a 404, 408, 425, 500, 501, 502, 503 or 504 error,
attempt to retry the request, exactly as if we just failed to connect to
the server.
To do so, add a new backend keyword, "retry-on".
It accepts a list of keywords, which can be "none" (never retry),
"conn-failure" (we failed to connect, or to do the SSL handshake),
"empty-response" (the server closed the connection without answering),
"response-timeout" (we timed out while waiting for the server response),
or "404", "408", "425", "500", "501", "502", "503" and "504".
The default is "conn-failure".
When deciding if we want to wake the task of an applet up, don't give up
if task_in_rq returns 1, as there's a race condition and another thread
may run it. Instead, always attempt to task_wakeup(), at worst the task
is already in the run queue, and nothing will happen.
If the interface is not in state SI_ST_CON or SI_ST_EST, don't bother
trying to send/recv data, we can't do it anyway, and if we're in SI_ST_TAR,
that may lead to adding the SI_FL_ERR flag back on the stream_interface,
while we don't want it.
This should be backported to 1.9.
In commit d7704b534, we introduced and expiration flag on the stream interface,
which is used for the connect, the queue and the turn around. Because the
turn around state isn't an error, the flag was reset in process_stream(), and
later in commit cff6411f9 when introducing the SI_FL_ERR flag, the cleanup
of the flag at this place was erroneously generalized.
To fix this, the SI_FL_EXP flag is only cleared at the end of the turn around
state, and nobody should clear the stream interface flags anymore.
This should be backported to 1.9, it has no known impact on older versions.
Don't inconditionally remove the SI_FL_ERR code in si_update_both(), which
is called at the end of process_stream(). Doing so was a bug that was there
since the flag was introduced, because we were always setting si->flags to
SI_FL_NONE, however we don't want to lose that one, except if we will retry
connecting, so only remove it in sess_update_st_cer().
This should be backported to 1.9.
This flag is set by the stream layer to request an abort, and results in
CF_SHUTR being set once the abort is performed. However by analogy with
the send side, the flag was removed once the CF_SHUTR flag was set, thus
we lose the information about the cause of the shutr. This is what creates
the confusion that sometimes arises between client and server aborts.
This patch makes sure we don't remove this flag anymore in this case.
All call places only use it to perform the shutr and already check it
against CF_SHUTR. So no condition needs to be updated to take this into
account.
Some later, more careful changes may consist in refining the conditions
where we report a client reset or a server reset to ignore SHUTR when
SHUTR_NOW is set so that we don't report such misleading information
anymore.
The flag CF_EOI is now set on the input channel when the flag CS_FL_EOI is set
on the corresponding conn_stream. In addition, if a read activity is reported
when this flag is set, the stream is woken up.
This patch should be backported to 1.9.
For conveniance, in HTTP muxes (h1 and h2), the end of the stream and the end of
the message are reported the same way to the stream, by setting the flag
CS_FL_EOS. In the stream-interface, when CS_FL_EOS is detected, a shutdown for
read is reported on the channel side. This is historical. With the legacy HTTP
layer, because the parsing is done by the stream in HTTP analyzers, the EOS
really means a shutdown for read.
Most of time, for muxes h1 and h2, it works pretty well, especially because the
keep-alive is handled by the muxes. The stream is only used for one
transaction. So mixing EOS and EOM is good enough. But not everytime. For now,
client aborts are only reported if it happens before the end of the request. It
is an error and it is properly handled. But because the EOS was already
reported, client aborts after the end of the request are silently
ignored. Eventually an error can be reported when the response is sent to the
client, if the sending fails. Otherwise, if the server does not reply fast
enough, an error is reported when the server timeout is reached. It is the
expected behaviour, excpect when the option abortonclose is set. In this case,
we must report an error when the client aborts. But as said before, this event
can be ignored. So to be short, for now, the abortonclose is broken.
In fact, it is a design problem and we have to rethink all channel's flags and
probably the conn-stream ones too. It is important to split EOS and EOM to not
loose information anymore. But it is not a small job and the refactoring will be
far from straightforward.
So for now, temporary flags are introduced. When the last read is received, the
flag CS_FL_READ_NULL is set on the conn-stream. This way, we can set the flag
SI_FL_READ_NULL on the stream interface. Both flags are persistant. And to be
sure to wake the stream, the event CF_READ_NULL is reported. So the stream will
always have the chance to handle the last read.
This patch must be backported to 1.9 because it will be used by another patch to
fix the option abortonclose.
The if-statement was converted into a while-loop in
7fe45698f5 to handle EINTR.
This special handling was later replaced in
0a03c0f022 by conn_sock_send.
The while-loop was not changed back and is not unconditionally
exited after one iteration, with no `continue` inside the body.
Replace by an if-statement.
Since a long time, the expiration date of a stream is only updated in
process_stream(). It is calculated, among others, using the channels expiration
dates for reads and writes (.rex and .wex values). But these values are updated
by the stream-interface. So when this happens at the connection layer, the
update is only done if the stream's task is woken up. Otherwise, the stream
expiration date is not immediatly updated. This leads to unexpected
behaviours. Time to time, users reported that the wrong timeout was hitted or
the wrong termination state was reported. This is partly because of this
bug.
Recently, we observed some blocked sessions for a while when big objects are
served from the cache applet. It seems only concern the clients not reading the
response. Because delivered objects are big, not all data can be sent. And
because delivered objects are big, data are fast forwarded (from the input to
the output with no stream wakeup). So in such situation, the stream expiration
date is never updated and no timeout is hitted. The session remains blocked
while the client remains connected.
This bug exists at least since HAProxy 1.5. But recent changes on the connection
layer make it more visible. It must be backported from 1.9 to 1.6. And with more
pain it should be backported to 1.5.
We still have an issue with asynchronous errors, which is that while
they don't truncate reads anymore, they might be missed during a
send() attempt. This can happen for example when processing a request
followed by undesired data for which the stream doesn't try to receive,
while the send side experiences an error (transfer aborted by the client).
In this case we definitely want all send() attempts to fail as soon as
the error was reported, even if it's only pending. This way we leave an
opportunity to the stream interface to try to receive the last data
pending in the buffer but it cannot send anymore and knows that there
is an error when trying to do so.
As long-time changes have accumulated over time, the exported functions
of the stream-interface were almost all prefixed "si_<something>" while
most private ones (mostly callbacks) were called "stream_int_<something>".
There were still a few confusing exceptions, which were addressed to
follow this shcme :
- stream_sock_read0(), only used internally, was renamed stream_int_read0()
and made static
- stream_int_notify() is only private and was made static
- stream_int_{check_timeouts,report_error,retnclose,register_handler,update}
were renamed si_<something>.
Now it is clearer when checking one of these if it risks to be used outside
or not.
The SUB_CAN_SEND/SUB_CAN_RECV enum values have been confusing a few
times, especially when checking them on reading. After some discussion,
it appears that calling them SUB_RETRY_SEND/SUB_RETRY_RECV more
accurately reflects their purpose since these events may only appear
after a first attempt to perform the I/O operation has failed or was
not completed.
In addition the wait_reason field in struct wait_event which carries
them makes one think that a single reason may happen at once while
it is in fact a set of events. Since the struct is called wait_event
it makes sense that this field is called "events" to indicate it's the
list of events we're subscribed to.
Last, the values for SUB_RETRY_RECV/SEND were swapped so that value
1 corresponds to recv and 2 to send, as is done almost everywhere else
in the code an in the shutdown() call.
There is an issue with some medium sized transfers occasionally not
shutting down at the end. Olivier tracked this to being caused by a
missing wakeup of process_stream(). What happens is that one of the
analysers sets CF_WAKE_WRITE to be woken up at the end of the transfer
to take note of the end of transaction, but a failed si_cs_send() at
the end of process_stream causes the call to be attempted again, with
CF_WAKE_WRITE lost. Then stream_int_notify() doesn't find any valid
condition to wake up process_stream(), and the stream stays there,
idling till the timeout.
In fact, CF_WAKE_WRITE has been designed for calling the analysers
to complete an operation without closing (keep-alive HTTP transfer
for instance). It only applies once the buffer is empty and there
is nothing left to be forwarded. In case the channel is closed, the
wakeup is already granted. So what we need here is to make sure to
wake process_stream() up in case the channel will not be closed and
it doesn't have anything left to be transferred. This is detected by
the lack of CF_AUTO_CLOSE and the emptiness of the buffer + to_forward
after a write activity. So now we take care of always waking the stream
up on end of transfers even if the analysers didn't subscribe to this
or if their subscription was lost.
CF_WAKE_WRITE should probably be killed now, though this first requires
careful inspection.
No backport is needed.
Cc: Olivier Houchard <ohouchard@haproxy.com>
Cc: Christopher Faulet <cfaulet@haproxy.com>
Commit d94f877cd ("BUG/MINOR: mux_pt: Set CS_FL_WANT_ROOM when count is
zero in rcv_buf() callback") triggered a pending issue with this flag,
which is that it's cleared too late and sometimes causes some Rx
transfers to stall. We need to clear it before attempting to receive
otherwise we may risk to see an earlier copy of the flag.
Note that it should probably be defined that this flag could be purged
on each invocation of mux->rcv_buf(), which would make sense.
No backport is needed.
In si_cs_recv(), report that arrive at the end of stream only if we were
indeed connected, we don't want that if the connection failed and we're about
to retry.
The flag CS_FL_EOS can be set while no data was received. So the flas
CS_FL_RCV_MORE is not set. In this case, the read0 was never processed by the
stream interface. To be sure to process it, the test on CS_FL_RCV_MORE has been
moved after the one on CS_FL_EOS.
CS_FL_RCV_MORE is used in two cases, to let the conn_stream
know there may be more data available, and to let it know that
it needs more room. We can't easily differentiate between the
two, and that may leads to hangs, so split it into two flags,
CS_FL_RCV_MORE, that means there may be more data, and
CS_FL_WANT_ROOM, that means we need more room.
This should not be backported.
After 8706c8131 ("BUG/MEDIUM: mux_pt: Always set CS_FL_RCV_MORE."), a
side effect caused failed receives to mark the buffer as missing room,
a flag that no other place can remove since it's empty. Ideally we need
a separate flag to mean "failed to deliver data by lack of room", but
in the mean time at the very least we must not mark as blocked an
empty buffer.
No backport is needed.
In si_cs_recv(), when there's an error on the connection or the conn_stream,
don't give up if CS_FL_RCV_MORE is set on the conn_stream, as it means there's
still data available.
In si_cs_send(), don't give up and subscribe if the connection is still
waiting for a SSL handshake. We will never be woken up once the handshake is
done if we're using HTTP/2. Instead, directly try to send data. When using
the mux_pt, if the handshake is not done yet, snd_buf() would return 0 and
we will subscribe anyway.
In si_cs_send(), some checks are done the CS flags en the connection flags
before calling snd_buf(). But these checks are useless because they have already
been done earlier in the function. The harder to figure out is the flag
CO_FL_SOCK_WR_SH. So it is now tested with CF_SHUTW at the beginning.
In si_cs_send, as said in comments, snd_buf() should only be called if there is
no data in the pipe anymore. But actually, this condition was not respected.
For the same reason than for the commit b46784b1c ("MINOR: stream-int: Notify
caller when an error is reported after a rcv_pipe()"), we return 1 after the
call to rcv_buf() in si_cs_send() to notify the caller some processing may be
triggered.
This patch is not flagged as a bug because no strange behaviour was yet observed
without it. It is just a proactive fix to be consistent.
In si_cs_send(), when an error is found on the CS or the connection at the
beginning of the function, we return 1 to notify the caller some processing may
be triggered. So, it seems logical to do the same after the call to rcv_pipe().
This patch is not flagged as a bug because no strange behaviour was yet observed
without it. It is just a proactive fix to be consistent.
The flag CS_FL_READ_PARTIAL can be set by the mux on the conn_stream to notify
the stream interface that some data were received. Is is used in si_cs_recv to
re-arm read timeout on the channel.
By setting the flag CO_RFL_KEEP_RSV when calling mux->rcv_buf, the
stream-interface notifies the mux it must keep some space to preserve the
buffer's reserve. This flag is only useful for multiplexers handling structured
data, because in such case, the stream-interface cannot know the real amount of
free space in the channel's buffer.
