First, we use atomic operations to update jobs/totalconn/actconn variables,
listener's nbconn variable and listener's counters. Then we add a lock on
listeners to protect access to their information. And finally, listener queues
(global and per proxy) are also protected by a lock. Here, because access to
these queues are unusal, we use the same lock for all queues instead of a global
one for the global queue and a lock per proxy for others.
This patch reorganize the shctx API in a generic storage API, separating
the shared SSL session handling from its core.
The shctx API only handles the generic data part, it does not know what
kind of data you use with it.
A shared_context is a storage structure allocated in a shared memory,
allowing its usage in a multithread or a multiprocess context.
The structure use 2 linked list, one containing the available blocks,
and another for the hot locked blocks. At initialization the available
list is filled with <maxblocks> blocks of size <blocksize>. An <extra>
space is initialized outside the list in case you need some specific
storage.
+-----------------------+--------+--------+--------+--------+----
| struct shared_context | extra | block1 | block2 | block3 | ...
+-----------------------+--------+--------+--------+--------+----
<-------- maxblocks --------->
* blocksize
The API allows to store content on several linked blocks. For example,
if you allocated blocks of 16 bytes, and you want to store an object of
60 bytes, the object will be allocated in a row of 4 blocks.
The API was made for LRU usage, each time you get an object, it pushes
the object at the end of the list. When it needs more space, it discards
The functions name have been renamed in a more logical way, the part
regarding shctx have been prefixed by shctx_ and the functions for the
shared ssl session cache have been prefixed by sh_ssl_sess_.
Move the ssl callback functions of the ssl shared session cache to
ssl_sock.c. The shctx functions still needs to be separated of the ssl
tree and data.
A bind_conf does contain a ssl_bind_conf, which already has a flag to know
if early data are activated, so use that, instead of adding a new flag in
the ssl_options field.
Add a new sample fetch, "ssl_fc_has_early", a boolean that will be true
if early data were sent, and a new action, "wait-for-handshake", if used,
the request won't be forwarded until the SSL handshake is done.
When compiled with Openssl >= 1.1.1, before attempting to do the handshake,
try to read any early data. If any early data is present, then we'll create
the session, read the data, and handle the request before we're doing the
handshake.
For this, we add a new connection flag, CO_FL_EARLY_SSL_HS, which is not
part of the CO_FL_HANDSHAKE set, allowing to proceed with a session even
before an SSL handshake is completed.
As early data do have security implication, we let the origin server know
the request comes from early data by adding the "Early-Data" header, as
specified in this draft from the HTTP working group :
https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/html/draft-ietf-httpbis-replay
Use Openssl-1.1.1 SSL_CTX_set_client_hello_cb to mimic BoringSSL early callback.
Native multi certificate and SSL/TLS method per certificate is now supported by
Openssl >= 1.1.1.
switchctx early callback is only supported for BoringSSL. To prepare
the support of openssl 1.1.1 early callback, convert CBS api to neutral
code to work with any ssl libs.
Now when ssl_sock_{to,from}_buf are called, if the connection doesn't
feature CO_FL_WILL_UPDATE, they will first retrieve the updated flags
using conn_refresh_polling_flags() before changing any flag, then call
conn_cond_update_sock_polling() before leaving, to commit such changes.
SSL records are 16kB max. When trying to send larger data chunks at once,
SSL_read() only processes 16kB and ssl_sock_from_buf() believes it means
the system buffers are full, which is not the case, contrary to raw_sock.
This is particularly noticeable with HTTP/2 when using a 64kB buffer with
multiple streams, as the mux buffer can start to fill up pretty quickly
in this situation, slowing down the data delivery.
in 32af203b75 ("REORG: cli: move ssl CLI functions to ssl_sock.c")
"set ssl tls-key" was accidentally replaced with "set ssl tls-keys"
(keys instead of key). This is undocumented and breaks upgrades from
1.6 to 1.7.
This patch restores "set ssl tls-key" and also registers a helptext.
This should be backported to 1.7.
Commit 872085ce "BUG/MINOR: ssl: ocsp response with 'revoked' status is correct"
introduce a regression. OCSP_single_get0_status can return -1 and haproxy must
generate an error in this case.
Thanks to Sander Hoentjen who have spotted the regression.
This patch should be backported in 1.7, 1.6 and 1.5 if the patch above is
backported.
BoringSSL switch OPENSSL_VERSION_NUMBER to 1.1.0 for compatibility.
Fix BoringSSL call and openssl-compat.h/#define occordingly.
This will not break openssl/libressl compat.
ocsp_status can be 'good', 'revoked', or 'unknown'. 'revoked' status
is a correct status and should not be dropped.
In case of certificate with OCSP must-stapling extension, response with
'revoked' status must be provided as well as 'good' status.
This patch can be backported in 1.7, 1.6 and 1.5.
For HTTP/2 we'll need some buffer-only equivalent functions to some of
the ones applying to channels and still squatting the bi_* / bo_*
namespace. Since these names have kept being misleading for quite some
time now and are really getting annoying, it's time to rename them. This
commit will use "ci/co" as the prefix (for "channel in", "channel out")
instead of "bi/bo". The following ones were renamed :
bi_getblk_nc, bi_getline_nc, bi_putblk, bi_putchr,
bo_getblk, bo_getblk_nc, bo_getline, bo_getline_nc, bo_inject,
bi_putchk, bi_putstr, bo_getchr, bo_skip, bi_swpbuf
The hour part of the timezone offset was multiplied by 60 instead of
3600, resulting in an inaccurate expiry. This bug was introduced in
1.6-dev1 by commit 4f3c87a ("BUG/MEDIUM: ssl: Fix to not serve expired
OCSP responses."), so this fix must be backported into 1.7 and 1.6.
smp_fetch_ssl_fc_cl_str as very limited usage (only work with openssl == 1.0.2
compiled with the option enable-ssl-trace). It use internal cipher.algorithm_ssl
attribut and SSL_CIPHER_standard_name (available with ssl-trace).
This patch implement this (debug) function in a standard way. It used common
SSL_CIPHER_get_name to display cipher name. It work with openssl >= 1.0.2
and boringssl.
Patch "MINOR: ssl: support ssl-min-ver and ssl-max-ver with crt-list"
introduce ssl_methods in struct ssl_bind_conf. struct bind_conf have now
ssl_methods and ssl_conf.ssl_methods (unused). It's error-prone. This patch
remove the duplicate structure to avoid any confusion.
Till now connections used to rely exclusively on file descriptors. It
was planned in the past that alternative solutions would be implemented,
leading to member "union t" presenting sock.fd only for now.
With QUIC, the connection will need to continue to exist but will not
rely on a file descriptor but a connection ID.
So this patch introduces a "connection handle" which is either a file
descriptor or a connection ID, to replace the existing "union t". We've
now removed the intermediate "struct sock" which was never used. There
is no functional change at all, though the struct connection was inflated
by 32 bits on 64-bit platforms due to alignment.
Commit 48a8332a introduce SSL_CTX_get0_privatekey in openssl-compat.h but
SSL_CTX_get0_privatekey access internal structure and can't be a candidate
to openssl-compat.h. The workaround with openssl < 1.0.2 is to use SSL_new
then SSL_get_privatekey.
With strict-sni, ssl connection will fail if no certificate match. Have no
certificate in bind line, fail on all ssl connections. It's ok with the
behavior of strict-sni. When 'generate-certificates' is set 'strict-sni' is
never used. When 'strict-sni' is set, default_ctx is never used. Allow to start
without certificate only in this case.
Use case is to start haproxy with ssl before customer start to use certificates.
Typically with 'crt' on a empty directory and 'strict-sni' parameters.
Since the commit f6b37c67 ["BUG/MEDIUM: ssl: in bind line, ssl-options after
'crt' are ignored."], the certificates generation is broken.
To generate a certificate, we retrieved the private key of the default
certificate using the SSL object. But since the commit f6b37c67, the SSL object
is created with a dummy certificate (initial_ctx).
So to fix the bug, we use directly the default certificate in the bind_conf
structure. We use SSL_CTX_get0_privatekey function to do so. Because this
function does not exist for OpenSSL < 1.0.2 and for LibreSSL, it has been added
in openssl-compat.h with the right #ifdef.
If a server presents an unexpected certificate to haproxy, that is, a
certificate that doesn't match the expected name as configured in
verifyhost or as requested using SNI, we want to store that precious
information. Fortunately we have access to the connection in the
verification callback so it's possible to store an error code there.
For this purpose we use CO_ER_SSL_MISMATCH_SNI (for when the cert name
didn't match the one requested using SNI) and CO_ER_SSL_MISMATCH for
when it doesn't match verifyhost.
Commit 2ab8867 ("MINOR: ssl: compare server certificate names to the SNI
on outgoing connections") introduced the ability to check server cert
names against the name provided with in the SNI, but verifyhost was kept
as a way to force the name to check against. This was a mistake, because :
- if an SNI is used, any static hostname in verifyhost will be wrong ;
worse, if it matches and doesn't match the SNI, the server presented
the wrong certificate ;
- there's no way to have a default name to check against for health
checks anymore because the point above mandates the removal of the
verifyhost directive
This patch reverses the ordering of the check : whenever SNI is used, the
name provided always has precedence (ie the server must always present a
certificate that matches the requested name). And if no SNI is provided,
then verifyhost is used, and will be configured to match the server's
default certificate name. This will work both when SNI is not used and
for health checks.
If the commit 2ab8867 is backported in 1.7 and/or 1.6, this one must be
backported too.
This patch fixes the commit 2ab8867 ("MINOR: ssl: compare server certificate
names to the SNI on outgoing connections")
When we check the certificate sent by a server, in the verify callback, we get
the SNI from the session (SSL_SESSION object). In OpenSSL, tlsext_hostname value
for this session is copied from the ssl connection (SSL object). But the copy is
done only if the "server_name" extension is found in the server hello
message. This means the server has found a certificate matching the client's
SNI.
When the server returns a default certificate not matching the client's SNI, it
doesn't set any "server_name" extension in the server hello message. So no SNI
is set on the SSL session and SSL_SESSION_get0_hostname always returns NULL.
To fix the problemn, we get the SNI directly from the SSL connection. It is
always defined with the value set by the client.
If the commit 2ab8867 is backported in 1.7 and/or 1.6, this one must be
backported too.
Note: it's worth mentionning that by making the SNI check work, we
introduce another problem by which failed SNI checks can cause
long connection retries on the server, and in certain cases the
SNI value used comes from the client. So this patch series must
not be backported until this issue is resolved.
The commit 5db33cbd "MEDIUM: ssl: ssl_methods implementation is reworked and
factored for min/max tlsxx" drop the case when ssl lib have removed SSLv3.
The commit 1e59fcc5 "BUG/MINOR: ssl: Be sure that SSLv3 connection methods
exist for openssl < 1.1.0" fix build but it's false because haproxy think
that ssl lib support SSLv3.
SSL_OP_NO_* are flags to set in ssl_options and is the way haproxy do the
link between ssl capabilities and haproxy configuration. (The mapping table
is done via methodVersions). SSL_OP_NO_* is set to 0 when ssl lib doesn't
support a new TLS version. Older version (like SSLv3) can be removed at
build or unsupported (like libressl). In all case OPENSSL_NO_SSL3 is define.
To keep the same logic, this patch alter SSL_OP_NO_SSLv3 to 0 when SSLv3 is
not supported by ssl lib (when OPENSSL_NO_SSL3 is define).
In ssl_sock_to_buf(), when we face a small read, we used to consider it
as an indication for the end of incoming data, as is the case with plain
text. The problem is that here it's quite different, SSL records are
returned at once so doing so make us wake all the upper layers for each
and every record. Given that SSL records are 16kB by default, this is
rarely observed unless the protocol employs small records or the buffers
are increased. But with 64kB buffers while trying to deal with HTTP/2
frames, the exchanges are obviously suboptimal as there are two messages
per frame (one for the frame header and another one for the frame payload),
causing the H2 parser to be woken up half of the times without being able
to proceed :
try=65536 ret=45
try=65536 ret=16384
try=49152 ret=9
try=49143 ret=16384
try=32759 ret=9
try=32750 ret=16384
try=16366 ret=9
try=32795 ret=27
try=49161 ret=9
try=49152 ret=16384
try=49116 ret=9
try=49107 ret=16384
try=32723 ret=9
try=32714 ret=16384
try=16330 ret=9
try=32831 ret=63
try=49161 ret=9
try=49152 ret=16384
try=49080 ret=9
try=49071 ret=2181
With this change, the buffer can safely be filled with all pending frames
at once when they are available.
When support for passing SNI to the server was added in 1.6-dev3, there
was no way to validate that the certificate presented by the server would
really match the name requested in the SNI, which is quite a problem as
it allows other (valid) certificates to be presented instead (when hitting
the wrong server or due to a man in the middle).
This patch adds the missing check against the value passed in the SNI.
The "verifyhost" value keeps precedence if set. If no SNI is used and
no verifyhost directive is specified, then the certificate name is not
checked (this is unchanged).
In order to extract the SNI value, it was necessary to make use of
SSL_SESSION_get0_hostname(), which appeared in openssl 1.1.0. This is
a trivial function which returns the value of s->tlsext_hostname, so
it was provided in the compat layer for older versions. After some
refinements from Emmanuel, it now builds with openssl 1.0.2, openssl
1.1.0 and boringssl. A test file was provided to ease testing all cases.
After some careful observation period it may make sense to backport
this to 1.7 and 1.6 as some users rightfully consider this limitation
as a bug.
Cc: Emmanuel Hocdet <manu@gandi.net>
Signed-off-by: Willy Tarreau <w@1wt.eu>
This is used to retrieve the TLS ALPN information from a connection. We
also support a fallback to NPN if ALPN doesn't find anything or is not
available on the existing implementation. It happens that depending on
the library version, either one or the other is available. NPN was
present in openssl 1.0.1 (very common) while ALPN is in 1.0.2 and onwards
(still uncommon at the time of writing). Clients are used to send either
one or the other to ensure a smooth transition.
For openssl 1.0.2, SSLv3_server_method and SSLv3_client_method are undefined if
OPENSSL_NO_SSL3_METHOD is set. So we must add a check on this macro before using
these functions.
This patch modifies the way to re-enable the connection from the async fd
handler calling conn_update_sock_polling instead of the conn_fd_handler.
It also ensures that the polling is really stopped on the async fd.
The Openssl's ASYNC API does'nt support moving buffers on SSL_read/write
This patch disables the ASYNC mode dynamically when the handshake
is left and re-enables it on reneg.
This patch ensure that the ASYNC fd handlers won't be wake up
too early, disabling the event cache for this fd on connection close
and when a WANT_ASYNC is rised by Openssl.
The calls to SSL_read/SSL_write/SSL_do_handshake before rising a real read
event from the ASYNC fd, generated an EAGAIN followed by a context switch
for some engines, or a blocked read for the others.
On connection close it resulted in a too early call to SSL_free followed
by a segmentation fault.
SSL/TLS version can be changed per certificat if and only if openssl lib support
earlier callback on handshake and, of course, is implemented in haproxy. It's ok
for BoringSSL. For Openssl, version 1.1.1 have such callback and could support it.
This patch cleanup the usage of set_version func with a more suitable name:
ctx_set_version. It introduce ssl_set_version func (unused for the moment).
This patch adds the support of a maximum of 32 engines
in async mode.
Some tests have been done using 2 engines simultaneously.
This patch also removes specific 'async' attribute from the connection
structure. All the code relies only on Openssl functions.
ssl-mode-async is a global configuration parameter which enables
asynchronous processing in OPENSSL for all SSL connections haproxy
handles. With SSL_MODE_ASYNC set, TLS I/O operations may indicate a
retry with SSL_ERROR_WANT_ASYNC with this mode set if an asynchronous
capable engine is used to perform cryptographic operations. Currently
async mode only supports one async-capable engine.
This is the latest version of the patchset which includes Emeric's
updates :
- improved async fd cleaning when openssl reports an fd to delete
- prevent conn_fd_handler from calling SSL_{read,write,handshake} until
the async fd is ready, as these operations are very slow and waste CPU
- postpone of SSL_free to ensure the async operation can complete and
does not cause a dereference a released SSL.
- proper removal of async fd from the fdtab and removal of the unused async
flag.
This patch adds the global 'ssl-engine' keyword. First arg is an engine
identifier followed by a list of default_algorithms the engine will
operate.
If the openssl version is too old, an error is reported when the option
is used.
In haproxy < 1.8, no-sslv3/no-tlsv1x are ignored when force-sslv3/force-tlsv1x
is used (without warning). With this patch, no-sslv3/no-tlsv1x are ignored when
ssl-min-ver or ssl-max-ver is used (with warning).
When all SSL/TLS versions are disable: generate an error, not a warning.
example: ssl-min-ver TLSV1.3 (or force-tlsv13) with a openssl <= 1.1.0.
'ssl-min-ver' and 'ssl-max-ver' with argument SSLv3, TLSv1.0, TLSv1.1, TLSv1.2
or TLSv1.3 limit the SSL negotiation version to a continuous range. ssl-min-ver
and ssl-max-ver should be used in replacement of no-tls* and no-sslv3. Warning
and documentation are set accordingly.
Plan is to add min-tlsxx max-tlsxx configuration, more consistent than no-tlsxx.
Find the real min/max versions (openssl capabilities and haproxy configuration)
and generate warning with bad versions range.
'no-tlsxx' can generate 'holes':
"The list of protocols available can be further limited using the SSL_OP_NO_X
options of the SSL_CTX_set_options or SSL_set_options functions. Clients should
avoid creating 'holes' in the set of protocols they support, when disabling a
protocol, make sure that you also disable either all previous or all subsequent
protocol versions. In clients, when a protocol version is disabled without
disabling all previous protocol versions, the effect is to also disable all
subsequent protocol versions."
To not break compatibility, "holes" is authorized with warning, because openssl
1.1.0 and boringssl deal with it (keep the upper or lower range depending the
case and version).
Plan is to add min-tlsxx max-tlsxx configuration, more consistent than no-tlsxx.
This patch introduce internal min/max and replace force-tlsxx implementation.
SSL method configuration is store in 'struct tls_version_filter'.
SSL method configuration to openssl setting is abstract in 'methodVersions' table.
With openssl < 1.1.0, SSL_CTX_set_ssl_version is used for force (min == max).
With openssl >= 1.1.0, SSL_CTX_set_min/max_proto_version is used.
Plan is to add min-tlsxx max-tlsxx configuration, more consistent than no-tlsxx.
min-tlsxx and max-tlsxx can be overwrite on local definition. This directives
should be the only ones needed in default-server.
To simplify next patches (rework of tls versions settings with min/max) all
ssl/tls version settings relative to default-server are reverted first:
remove: 'sslv3', 'tls*', 'no-force-sslv3', 'no-force-tls*'.
remove from default-server: 'no-sslv3', 'no-tls*'.
Note:
. force-tlsxx == min-tlsxx + max-tlsxx : would be ok in default-server.
. no-tlsxx is keep for compatibility: should not be propagated to default-server.
This patch replaces the calls to TLSvX_X_client/server/_method
by the new TLS_client/server_method and it uses the new functions
SSL_set_min_proto_version and SSL_set_max_proto_version, setting them
at the wanted protocol version using 'force-' statements.
This patch makes 'default-server' directives support 'sni' settings.
A field 'sni_expr' has been added to 'struct server' to temporary
stores SNI expressions as strings during both 'default-server' and 'server'
lines parsing. So, to duplicate SNI expressions from 'default-server' 'sni' setting
for new 'server' instances we only have to "strdup" these strings as this is
often done for most of the 'server' settings.
Then, sample expressions are computed calling sample_parse_expr() (only for 'server'
instances).
A new function has been added to produce the same error output as before in case
of any error during 'sni' settings parsing (display_parser_err()).
Should not break anything.
This patch makes 'default-server' directive support 'verifyhost' setting.
Note: there was a little memory leak when several 'verifyhost' arguments were
supplied on the same 'server' line.
This patch makes 'default-server' directive support 'send-proxy-v2-ssl'
(resp. 'send-proxy-v2-ssl-cn') setting.
A new keyword 'no-send-proxy-v2-ssl' (resp. 'no-send-proxy-v2-ssl-cn') has been
added to disable 'send-proxy-v2-ssl' (resp. 'send-proxy-v2-ssl-cn') setting both
in 'server' and 'default-server' directives.
This patch makes 'default-server' directive support 'ssl' setting.
A new keyword 'no-ssl' has been added to disable this setting both
in 'server' and 'default-server' directives.
This patch makes 'default-server' directive support 'no-sslv3' (resp. 'no-ssl-reuse',
'no-tlsv10', 'no-tlsv11', 'no-tlsv12', and 'no-tls-tickets') setting.
New keywords 'sslv3' (resp. 'ssl-reuse', 'tlsv10', 'tlsv11', 'tlsv12', and
'tls-no-tickets') have been added to disable these settings both in 'server' and
'default-server' directives.
This patch makes 'default-server' directive support 'force-sslv3'
and 'force-tlsv1[0-2]' settings.
New keywords 'no-force-sslv3' (resp. 'no-tlsv1[0-2]') have been added
to disable 'force-sslv3' (resp. 'force-tlsv1[0-2]') setting both in 'server' and
'default-server' directives.
This patch makes 'default-server' directive support 'check-ssl' setting
to enable SSL for health checks.
A new keyword 'no-check-ssl' has been added to disable this setting both in
'server' and 'default-server' directives.
SSL_CTX_set_ecdh_auto is declared (when present) with #define. A simple #ifdef
avoid to list all cases of ssllibs. It's a placebo in new ssllibs. It's ok with
openssl 1.0.1, 1.0.2, 1.1.0, libressl and boringssl.
Thanks to Piotr Kubaj for postponing and testing with libressl.
Invalid OCSP file (for example empty one that can be used to enable
OCSP response to be set dynamically later) causes errors that are
placed on OpenSSL error stack. Those errors are not cleared so
anything that checks this stack later will fail.
Following configuration:
bind :443 ssl crt crt1.pem crt crt2.pem
With following files:
crt1.pem
crt1.pem.ocsp - empty one
crt2.pem.rsa
crt2.pem.ecdsa
Will fail to load.
This patch should be backported to 1.7.
Use SSL_set_ex_data/SSL_get_ex_data standard API call to store capture.
We need to avoid internal structures/undocumented calls usage to try to
control the beast and limit painful compatibilities.
Bug introduced with "removes SSL_CTX_set_ssl_version call and cleanup CTX
creation": ssl_sock_new_ctx is called before all the bind line is parsed.
The fix consists of separating the use of default_ctx as the initialization
context of the SSL connection via bind_conf->initial_ctx. Initial_ctx contains
all the necessary parameters before performing the selection of the CTX:
default_ctx is processed as others ctx without unnecessary parameters.
This new sample-fetches captures the cipher list offer by the client
SSL connection during the client-hello phase. This is useful for
fingerprint the SSL connection.
BoringSSL doesn't support SSL_CTX_set_ssl_version. To remove this call, the
CTX creation is cleanup to clarify what is happening. SSL_CTX_new is used to
match the original behavior, in order: force-<method> according the method
version then the default method with no-<method> options.
OPENSSL_NO_SSL3 error message is now in force-sslv3 parsing (as force-tls*).
For CTX creation in bind environement, all CTX set related to the initial ctx
are aggregate to ssl_sock_new_ctx function for clarity.
Tests with crt-list have shown that server_method, options and mode are
linked to the initial CTX (default_ctx): all ssl-options are link to each
bind line and must be removed from crt-list.
Extract from RFC 6066:
"If the server understood the ClientHello extension but does not recognize
the server name, the server SHOULD take one of two actions: either abort the
handshake by sending a fatal-level unrecognized_name(112) alert or continue the
handshake. It is NOT RECOMMENDED to send a warning-level unrecognized_name(112)
alert, because the client's behavior in response to warning-level alerts is
unpredictable. If there is a mismatch between the server name used by the
client application and the server name of the credential chosen by the server,
this mismatch will become apparent when the client application performs the
server endpoint identification, at which point the client application will have
to decide whether to proceed with the communication."
Thanks Roberto Guimaraes for the bug repport, spotted with openssl-1.1.0.
This fix must be backported.
SSL verify and client_CA inherits from the initial ctx (default_ctx).
When a certificate is found, the SSL connection environment must be replaced by
the certificate configuration (via SSL_set_verify and SSL_set_client_CA_list).
This patch used boringssl's callback to analyse CLientHello before any
handshake to extract key signature capabilities.
Certificat with better signature (ECDSA before RSA) is choosed
transparenty, if client can support it. RSA and ECDSA certificates can
be declare in a row (without order). This makes it possible to set
different ssl and filter parameter with crt-list.
Commit 405ff31 ("BUG/MINOR: ssl: assert on SSL_set_shutdown with BoringSSL")
introduced a regression causing some random crashes apparently due to
memory corruption. The issue is the use of SSL_CTX_set_quiet_shutdown()
instead of SSL_set_quiet_shutdown(), making it use a different structure
and causing the flag to be put who-knows-where.
Many thanks to Jarno Huuskonen who reported this bug early and who
bisected the issue to spot this patch. No backport is needed, this
is 1.8-specific.
A recent patch to support BoringSSL caused this warning to appear on
OpenSSL 1.1.0 :
src/ssl_sock.c:3062:4: warning: statement with no effect [-Wunused-value]
It's caused by SSL_CTX_set_ecdh_auto() which is now only a macro testing
that the last argument is zero, and the result is not used here. Let's
just kill it for both versions.
Tested with 0.9.8, 1.0.0, 1.0.1, 1.0.2, 1.1.0. This fix may be backported
to 1.7 if the boringssl fix is as well.
Limitations:
. disable force-ssl/tls (need more work)
should be set earlier with SSL_CTX_new (SSL_CTX_set_ssl_version is removed)
. disable generate-certificates (need more work)
introduce SSL_NO_GENERATE_CERTIFICATES to disable generate-certificates.
Cleanup some #ifdef and type related to boringssl env.
crt-list is extend to support ssl configuration. You can now have
such line in crt-list <file>:
mycert.pem [npn h2,http/1.1]
Support include "npn", "alpn", "verify", "ca_file", "crl_file",
"ecdhe", "ciphers" configuration and ssl options.
"crt-base" is also supported to fetch certificates.
The output of whether prefer-server-ciphers is supported by OpenSSL
actually always show yes in 1.8, because SSL_OP_CIPHER_SERVER_PREFERENCE
is redefined before the actual check in src/ssl_sock.c, since it was
moved from here from src/haproxy.c.
Since this is not really relevant anymore as we don't support OpenSSL
< 0.9.7 anyway, this change just removes this output.
With BoringSSL:
SSL_set_shutdown: Assertion `(SSL_get_shutdown(ssl) & mode) == SSL_get_shutdown(ssl)' failed.
"SSL_set_shutdown causes ssl to behave as if the shutdown bitmask (see SSL_get_shutdown)
were mode. This may be used to skip sending or receiving close_notify in SSL_shutdown by
causing the implementation to believe the events already happened.
It is an error to use SSL_set_shutdown to unset a bit that has already been set.
Doing so will trigger an assert in debug builds and otherwise be ignored.
Use SSL_CTX_set_quiet_shutdown instead."
Change logic to not notify on SSL_shutdown when connection is not clean.
"X509_get_pubkey() attempts to decode the public key for certificate x.
If successful it returns the public key as an EVP_PKEY pointer with its
reference count incremented: this means the returned key must be freed
up after use."
Calling SSL_set_tlsext_host_name() on the current SSL ctx has no effect
if the session is being resumed because the hostname is already stored
in the session and is not advertised again in subsequent connections.
It's visible when enabling SNI and health checks at the same time because
checks do not send an SNI and regular traffic reuses the same connection,
resulting in no SNI being sent.
The only short-term solution is to reset the reused session when the
SNI changes compared to the previous one. It can make the server-side
performance suffer when SNIs are interleaved but it will work. A better
long-term solution would be to keep a small cache of a few contexts for
a few SNIs.
Now with SSL_set_session(ctx, NULL) it works. This needs to be double-
checked though. The man says that SSL_set_session() frees any previously
existing context. Some people report a bit of breakage when calling
SSL_set_session(NULL) on openssl 1.1.0a (freed session not reusable at
all though it's not an issue for now).
This needs to be backported to 1.7 and 1.6.
Historically a lot of SSL global settings were stored into the global
struct, but we've reached a point where there are 3 ifdefs in it just
for this, and others in haproxy.c to initialize it.
This patch moves all the private fields to a new struct "global_ssl"
stored in ssl_sock.c. This includes :
char *crt_base;
char *ca_base;
char *listen_default_ciphers;
char *connect_default_ciphers;
int listen_default_ssloptions;
int connect_default_ssloptions;
int tune.sslprivatecache; /* Force to use a private session cache even if nbproc > 1 */
unsigned int tune.ssllifetime; /* SSL session lifetime in seconds */
unsigned int tune.ssl_max_record; /* SSL max record size */
unsigned int tune.ssl_default_dh_param; /* SSL maximum DH parameter size */
int tune.ssl_ctx_cache; /* max number of entries in the ssl_ctx cache. */
The "tune" part was removed (useless here) and the occasional "ssl"
prefixes were removed as well. Thus for example instead of
global.tune.ssl_default_dh_param
we now have :
global_ssl.default_dh_param
A few initializers were present in the constructor, they could be brought
back to the structure declaration.
A few other entries had to stay in global for now. They concern memory
calculationn (used in haproxy.c) and stats (used in stats.c).
The code is already much cleaner now, especially for global.h and haproxy.c
which become readable.
tlskeys_finalize_config() was the only reason for haproxy.c to still
require ifdef and includes for ssl_sock. This one fits perfectly well
in the late initializers so it was changed to be registered with
hap_register_post_check().
Now we can simply check the transport layer at run time and decide
whether or not to initialize or destroy these entries. This removes
other ifdefs and includes from cfgparse.c, haproxy.c and hlua.c.
There are still a lot of #ifdef USE_OPENSSL in the code (still 43
occurences) because we never know if we can directly access ssl_sock
or not. This patch attacks the problem differently by providing a
way for transport layers to register themselves and for users to
retrieve the pointer. Unregistered transport layers will point to NULL
so it will be easy to check if SSL is registered or not. The mechanism
is very inexpensive as it relies on a two-entries array of pointers,
so the performance will not be affected.
Instead of hard-coding all SSL destruction in cfgparse.c and haproxy.c,
we now register this new function as the transport layer's destroy_bind_conf()
and call it only when defined. This removes some non-obvious SSL-specific
code and #ifdefs from cfgparse.c and haproxy.c
Instead of hard-coding all SSL preparation in cfgparse.c, we now register
this new function as the transport layer's prepare_bind_conf() and call it
only when definied. This removes some non-obvious SSL-specific code from
cfgparse.c as well as a #ifdef.
Most of the SSL functions used to have a proxy argument which was mostly
used to be able to emit clean errors using Alert(). First, many of them
were converted to memprintf() and don't require this pointer anymore.
Second, the rare which still need it also have either a bind_conf argument
or a server argument, both of which carry a pointer to the relevant proxy.
So let's now get rid of it, it needlessly complicates the API and certain
functions already have many arguments.
A mistake was made when the socket layer was cut into proto and
transport, the transport was attached to the listener while all
listeners in a single "bind" line always have exactly the same
transport. It doesn't seem obvious but this is the reason why there
are so many #ifdefs USE_OPENSSL in cfgparse : a lot of operations
have to be open-coded because cfgparse only manipulates bind_conf
and we don't have the information of the transport layer here.
Very little code makes use of the transport layer, mainly session
setup and log. These places can afford an extra pointer indirection
(the listener points to the bind_conf). This change is thus very small,
it saves a little bit of memory (8B per listener) and makes the code
more flexible.
ssl_sock functions don't mark pointers as NULL after freeing them. So
if a "bind" line specifies some SSL settings without the "ssl" keyword,
they will get freed at the end of check_config_validity(), then freed
a second time on exit. Simply mark the pointers as NULL to fix this.
This fix needs to be backported to 1.7 and 1.6.
We have a bug when SSL reuse is disabled on the server side : we reset
the context but do not set it to NULL, causing a multiple free of the
same entry. It seems like this bug cannot appear as-is with the current
code (or the conditions to get it are not obvious) but it did definitely
strike when trying to fix another bug with the SNI which forced a new
handshake.
This fix should be backported to 1.7, 1.6 and 1.5.
The following keywords were still parsed in cfgparse and were moved
to ssl_sock to remove some #ifdefs :
"tune.ssl.cachesize", "tune.ssl.default-dh-param", "tune.ssl.force-private-cache",
"tune.ssl.lifetime", "tune.ssl.maxrecord", "tune.ssl.ssl-ctx-cache-size".
It's worth mentionning that some of them used to have incorrect sign
checks possibly resulting in some negative values being used. All of
them are now checked for being positive.
This removes 2 #ifdefs and makes the code much cleaner. The controls
are still there and the two parsers have been merged into a single
function ssl_parse_global_ca_crt_base().
It's worth noting that there's still a check to prevent a change when
the value was already specified. This test seems useless and possibly
counter-productive, it may have to be revisited later, but for now it
was implemented identically.
This one now migrates to the general purpose cli.p0 for the ref pointer,
cli.i0 for the dump_all flag and cli.i1 for the dump_keys_index. A few
comments were added.
The applet.h file doesn't depend on openssl anymore. It's worth noting
that the previous dependency was accidental and only used to work because
all files including this one used to have openssl included prior to
loading this file.
Fixing the build using LibreSSL as OpenSSL implementation.
Currently, LibreSSL 2.4.4 provides the same API of OpenSSL 1.0.1x,
but it redefine the OpenSSL version number as 2.0.x, breaking all
checks with OpenSSL 1.1.x.
The patch solves the issue checking the definition of the symbol
LIBRESSL_VERSION_NUMBER when Openssl 1.1.x features are requested.
The recent CLI reorganization managed to break these two commands
by having their parser return 1 (indicating an end of processing)
instead of 0 to indicate new calls to the io handler were needed.
Namely the faulty commits are :
69e9644 ("REORG: cli: move show stat resolvers to dns.c")
32af203 ("REORG: cli: move ssl CLI functions to ssl_sock.c")
The fix is trivial and there is no other loss of functionality. Thanks
to Dragan Dosen for reporting the issue and the faulty commits. The
backport is needed in 1.7.
Before this change, trash is being used to create certificate filename
to read in care Mutli-Cert are in used. But then ssl_sock_load_ocsp()
modify trash leading to potential wrong information given in later error
message.
This also blocks any further use of certificate filename for other
usage, like ongoing patch to support Certificate Transparency handling
in Multi-Cert bundle.
In the last release a lot of the structures have become opaque for an
end user. This means the code using these needs to be changed to use the
proper functions to interact with these structures instead of trying to
manipulate them directly.
This does not fix any deprecations yet that are part of 1.1.0, it only
ensures that it can be compiled against that version and is still
compatible with older ones.
[wt: openssl-0.9.8 doesn't build with it, there are conflicts on certain
function prototypes which we declare as inline here and which are
defined differently there. But openssl-0.9.8 is not supported anymore
so probably it's OK to go without it for now and we'll see later if
some users still need it. Emeric has reviewed this change and didn't
spot anything obvious which requires special care. Let's try it for
real now]
Today, the certificate are indexed int he SNI tree using their CN and the
list of thier AltNames. So, Some certificates have the same names in the
CN and one of the AltNames entries.
Typically Let's Encrypt duplicate the the DNS name in the CN and the
AltName.
This patch prevents the creation of identical entries in the trees. It
checks the same DNS name and the same SSL context.
If the same certificate is registered two time it will be duplicated.
This patch should be backported in the 1.6 and 1.5 version.
Add some debug trace when haproxy is configured in debug & verbose mode.
This is useful for openssl tests. Typically, the error "SSL handshake
failure" can be caused by a lot of protocol error. This patch details
the encountered error. For exemple:
OpenSSL error 0x1408a0c1: ssl3_get_client_hello: no shared cipher
Note that my compilator (gcc-4.7) refuse to considers the function
ssl_sock_dump_errors() as inline. The condition "if" ensure that the
content of the function is not executed in normal case. It should be
a pity to call a function just for testing its execution condition, so
I use the macro "forceinline".
Roberto Guimaraes reported that Valgrind complains about a leak
in ssl_get_dh_1024().
This is caused caused by an oversight in ssl_sock_load_dh_params(),
where local_dh_1024 is always replaced by a new DH object even if
it already holds one. This patch simply checks whether local_dh_1024
is NULL before calling ssl_get_dh_1024().
This reverts commit 0ea4c23ca7.
Certain very simple confs randomly segfault upon startup with openssl 1.0.2
with this patch, which seems to indicate a use after free. Better drop it
and let valgrind complain about the potential leak.
Also it's worth noting that the man page for SSL_CTX_set_tmp_dh() makes no
mention about whether or not the element should be freed, and the example
provided does not use it either.
This fix should be backported to 1.6 and 1.5 where the patch was just
included.
I just noticed that SSL wouldn't build anymore since this afternoon's patch :
src/ssl_sock.c: In function 'ssl_sock_load_multi_cert':
src/ssl_sock.c:1982:26: warning: left-hand operand of comma expression has no effect [-Wunused-value]
for (i = 0; i < fcount, i++)
^
src/ssl_sock.c:1982:31: error: expected ';' before ')' token
for (i = 0; i < fcount, i++)
^
Makefile:791: recipe for target 'src/ssl_sock.o' failed
make: *** [src/ssl_sock.o] Error 1
SNI filters used to be ignored with multicerts (eg: those providing
ECDSA and RSA at the same time). This patch makes them work like
other certs.
Note: most of the changes in this patch are due to an extra level of
indent, read it with "git show -b".
Valgrind reports that the memory allocated in ssl_get_dh_1024() was leaking. Upon further inspection of openssl code, it seems that SSL_CTX_set_tmp_dh makes a copy of the data, so calling DH_free afterwards makes sense.
Emeric found that some certificate files that were valid with the old method
(the one with the explicit name involving SSL_CTX_use_PrivateKey_file()) do
not work anymore with the new one (the one trying to load multiple cert types
using PEM_read_bio_PrivateKey()). With the last one, the private key couldn't
be loaded.
The difference was related to the ordering in the PEM file was different. The
old method would always work. The new method only works if the private key is
at the top, or if it appears as an "EC" private key. The cause in fact is that
we never rewind the BIO between the various calls. So this patch moves the
loading of the private key as the first step, then it rewinds the BIO, and
then it loads the cert and the chain. With this everything works.
No backport is needed, this issue came with the recent addition of the
multi-cert support.
Instead of repeating the type of the LHS argument (sizeof(struct ...))
in calls to malloc/calloc, we directly use the pointer
name (sizeof(*...)). The following Coccinelle patch was used:
@@
type T;
T *x;
@@
x = malloc(
- sizeof(T)
+ sizeof(*x)
)
@@
type T;
T *x;
@@
x = calloc(1,
- sizeof(T)
+ sizeof(*x)
)
When the LHS is not just a variable name, no change is made. Moreover,
the following patch was used to ensure that "1" is consistently used as
a first argument of calloc, not the last one:
@@
@@
calloc(
+ 1,
...
- ,1
)
In C89, "void *" is automatically promoted to any pointer type. Casting
the result of malloc/calloc to the type of the LHS variable is therefore
unneeded.
Most of this patch was built using this Coccinelle patch:
@@
type T;
@@
- (T *)
(\(lua_touserdata\|malloc\|calloc\|SSL_get_app_data\|hlua_checkudata\|lua_newuserdata\)(...))
@@
type T;
T *x;
void *data;
@@
x =
- (T *)
data
@@
type T;
T *x;
T *data;
@@
x =
- (T *)
data
Unfortunately, either Coccinelle or I is too limited to detect situation
where a complex RHS expression is of type "void *" and therefore casting
is not needed. Those cases were manually examined and corrected.
Olivier Doucet reported the issue on the ML and tested that when using
more than TLS_TICKETS_NO keys in the file, the CPU usage is much higeher
than expected.
Lukas Tribus then provided a test case which showed that resumption doesn't
work at all in that case.
This fix needs to be backported to 1.6.
Signed-off-by: Nenad Merdanovic <nmerdan@anine.io>
Technically speaking, many SSL sample fetch functions act on the
connection and depend on USE_L5CLI on the client side, which means
they're usable as soon as a handshake is completed on a connection.
This means that the test consisting in refusing to call them when
the stream is NULL will prevent them from working when we implement
the tcp-request session ruleset. Better fix this now. The fix consists
in using smp->sess->origin when they're called for the front connection,
and smp->strm->si[1].end when called for the back connection.
There is currently no known side effect for this issue, though it would
better be backported into 1.6 so that the code base remains consistend.
Since commit 6879ad3 ("MEDIUM: sample: fill the struct sample with the
session, proxy and stream pointers") merged in 1.6-dev2, the sample
contains the pointer to the stream and sample fetch functions as well
as converters use it heavily.
The problem is that earlier commit 87b0966 ("REORG/MAJOR: session:
rename the "session" entity to "stream"") had split the session and
stream resulting in the possibility for smp->strm to be NULL before
the stream was initialized. This is what happens in tcp-request
connection rulesets, as discovered by Baptiste.
The sample fetch functions must now check that smp->strm is valid
before using it. An alternative could consist in using a dummy stream
with nothing in it to avoid some checks but it would only result in
deferring them to the next step anyway, and making it harder to detect
that a stream is valid or the dummy one.
There is still an issue with variables which requires a complete
independant fix. They use strm->sess to find the session with strm
possibly NULL and passed as an argument. All call places indirectly
use smp->strm to build strm. So the problem is there but the API needs
to be changed to remove this duplicate argument that makes it much
harder to know what pointer to use.
This fix must be backported to 1.6, as well as the next one fixing
variables.
Owen Marshall reported an issue depending on the server keywords order in the
configuration.
Working line :
server dev1 <ip>:<port> check inter 5000 ssl verify none sni req.hdr(Host)
Non working line :
server dev1 <ip>:<port> check inter 5000 ssl sni req.hdr(Host) verify none
Indeed, both parse_server() and srv_parse_sni() modified the current argument
offset at the same time. To fix the issue, srv_parse_sni() can work on a local
copy ot the offset, leaving parse_server() responsible of the actual value.
This fix must be backported to 1.6.
After seeing previous ALPN fix, I suspected that NPN code was wrong
as well, and indeed it was since ALPN was copied from it. This fix
must be backported into 1.6 and 1.5.
The first time I tried it (1.6.3) I got a segmentation fault :(
After some investigation with gdb and valgrind I found the
problem. memcpy() copies past an allocated buffer in
"bind_parse_alpn". This patch fixes it.
[wt: this fix must be backported into 1.6 and 1.5]
The serial number for a generated certificate was computed using the requested
servername, without any variable/random part. It is not a problem from the
moment it is not regenerated.
But if the cache is disabled or when the certificate is evicted from the cache,
we may need to regenerate it. It is important to not reuse the same serial
number for the new certificate. Else clients (especially browsers) trigger a
warning because 2 certificates issued by the same CA have the same serial
number.
So now, the serial is a static variable initialized with now_ms (internal date
in milliseconds) and incremented at each new certificate generation.
(Ref MPS-2031)
Added support for loading mutiple certs into shared contexts when they
are specified in a crt-list
Note that it's not practical to support SNI filters with multicerts, so
any SNI filters that's provided to the crt-list is ignored if a
multi-cert opertion is used.
