Since commit ae024ced0 ("MEDIUM: stream-int/stream: Use connect expiration
instead of SI expiration"), the connect expiration date is per-stream. So
there is only one expiration date instead of one per side, front and
back. So when a stream-connector is processed, we must test if it is a
frontend or a backend stconn before updating the connect expiration
date. Indeed, the frontend stconn must not reset the connect expiration
date.
This bug may have several side effect. One known bug is about peer sessions
blocked because the frontend peer applet is in ST_CLO state and its backend
connection is in ST_TAR state but without connect expiration date.
This patch should fix the issue #1791 and #1792. It must be backported to
2.6.
As reported in github issue #1765, some people get trapped into building
haproxy and companion libraries on Windows using a compiler following the
LLP64 model. This has no chance to work, and definitely causes nasty bugs
everywhere when pointers are passed as longs. Let's save them time and
detect this at boot time.
The message and detection was factored with the existing one for -fwrapv
since we need the same info and actions.
This should be backported to all recent supported versions (the ones
that are likely to be tried on such platforms when people don't know).
When updating from 2.4 to 2.6, the child->reloads++ instruction changed
place, resulting in a former worker from the 2.4 process, still
identified as a current worker once in 2.6, because its reload counter
is still 0.
Unfortunately this counter is used to chose the mworker_proc structure
that will be used for the new worker.
What happens next, is that the mworker_proc structure of the previous
process is selected, and this one has ipc_fd[1] set to -1, because this
structure was supposed to be in the master.
The process then forks, and mworker_sockpair_register_per_thread() tries
to register ipc_fd[1] which is set to -1, instead of the fd of the new
socketpair.
This patch fixes the issue by checking if child->pid is equal to -1 when
selecting proc_self. This way we could be sure it wasn't a previous
process.
Should fix issue #1785.
This must be backported as far as 2.4 to fix the issue related to the
reload computation difference. However backporting it in every stable
branch will enforce the reload process.
Stream data reception is incorrect when dealing with a partially new
offset with some data already consumed out of the RX buffer. In this
case, data length is adjusted but not the data buffer. In most cases,
ncb_add() operation will be rejected as already stored data does not
correspond with the new inserted offset. This will result in an invalid
CONNECTION_CLOSE with PROTOCOL_VIOLATION.
To fix this, buffer pointer is advanced while the length is reduced.
This can be reproduced with a POST request and patching haproxy to call
qcc_recv() multiple times by copying a quic_stream frame with different
offsets.
Must be backported to 2.6.
Since e8422bf ("MEDIUM: global: remove the relative_pid from global and
mworker"), the relative pid prefix is not tested anymore on the master
CLI. Which means any value will fall into the "1" process.
Since we removed the nbproc, only the "1" and the "0" (master) value are
correct, any other value should return an error.
Fix issue #1793.
This must be backported as far as 2.5.
Enhance the errors and warnings when trying to load a ca-file with
ssl_store_load_locations_file().
Add errors from ERR_get_error() and strerror to give more information to
the user.
In commit cfdd20a0b ("MEDIUM: fd: support broadcasting updates for foreign
groups in updt_fd_polling") we decided to pick a random thread number among
a set of candidates for a wakeup in case we need an instant change. But the
thread count range was wrong (MAX_THREADS) instead of tg->count, resulting
in random crashes when thread groups are > 1 and MAX_THREADS > 64.
No backport is needed, this was introduced in 2.7-dev2.
In src/ev_epoll.c, a CHECK_IF() is guarded by an if statement. So, when the
macro is empty, GCC (at least 11.3.1) is not happy because there is an if
statement with an empty body without braces... It is handled by
"-Wempty-body" option.
So, braces are added and GCC is now happy.
No backport needed.
As specified by RFC 9000, it is forbidden to send a CONNECTION_CLOSE of
type 0x1d (CONNECTION_CLOSE_APP) in an Initial or Handshake packet. It
must be converted to type 0x1c (CONNECTION_CLOSE) with APPLICATION_ERROR
code.
CONNECTION_CLOSE_APP are generated by QUIC MUX interaction. Thus,
special care must be taken when dealing with a 0-RTT packet, as this is
the only case where the MUX can be instantiated and quic-conn still on
the Initial or Handshake encryption level.
To enforce RFC 9000, xprt build packet function is now responsible to
translate a CONNECTION_CLOSE_APP if still on Initial/Handshake
encryption. This process is done in a dedicated function named
qc_build_cc_frm().
Without this patch, BUG_ON() statement in qc_build_frm() will be
triggered when building a CONNECTION_CLOSE_APP frame on Initial or
Handshake level. This is because QUIC_FT_CONNECTION_CLOSE_APP frame
builder mask does not allow these encryption levels, as opposed to
QUIC_FT_CONNECTION_CLOSE builder. This crash was reproduced by modifying
the H3 layer to force emission of a CONNECTION_CLOSE_APP on first frame
of a 0-RTT session.
Note however that CONNECTION_CLOSE emission during Handshake is a
complicated process for the server. For the moment, this is still
incomplete on haproxy side. RFC 9000 requires to emit it multiple times
in several packets under different encryption levels, depending on what
we know about the client encryption context.
This patch should be backported up to 2.6.
It looks like OpenSSL 1.0.2 returns an error when trying to insert a
certificate whis is already present in a X509_STORE.
This patch simply ignores the X509_R_CERT_ALREADY_IN_HASH_TABLE error if
emitted.
Should fix part of issue #1780.
Must be backported in 2.6.
When the resolv.conf file is empty or there is no resolv.conf file, an
empty resolvers will be created, which emits a warning during the
postparsing step.
This patch fixes the problem by freeing the resolvers section if the
parsing failed or if the nameserver list is empty.
Must be backported in 2.6, the previous patch which introduces
resolvers_destroy() is also required.
The first approach in commit 288dc1d8e ("BUG/MEDIUM: tools: avoid calling
dlsym() in static builds") relied on dlopen() but on certain configs (at
least gcc-4.8+ld-2.27+glibc-2.17) it used to catch situations where it
ought not fail.
Let's have a second try on this using dladdr() instead. The variable was
renamed "build_is_static" as it's exactly what's being detected there.
We could even take it for reporting in -vv though that doesn't seem very
useful. At least the variable was made global to ease inspection via the
debugger, or in case it's useful later.
Now it properly detects a static build even with gcc-4.4+glibc-2.11.1 and
doesn't crash anymore.
Since 2.4 with commit 64192392c ("MINOR: tools: add functions to retrieve
the address of a symbol"), we can resolve symbols. However some old glibc
crash in dlsym() when the program is statically built.
Fortunately even on these old libs we can detect lack of support by
calling dlopen(NULL). Normally it returns a handle to the current
program, but on a static build it returns NULL. This is sufficient to
refrain from calling dlsym() (which will be of very limited use anyway),
so we check this once at boot and use the result when needed.
This may be backported to 2.4. On stable versions, be careful to place
the init code inside an if/endif guard that checks for DL support.
Since these are not used anymore, let's now remove them. Given the
number of places where we're using ti->ldit_bit, maybe an equivalent
might be useful though.
We're still facing the situation where it's impossible to update an FD
for a foreign group. That's of particular concern when disabling/enabling
listeners (e.g. pause/resume on signals) since we don't decide which thread
gets the signal and it needs to process all listeners at once.
Fortunately, not that much is unprotected in FDs. This patch adds a test for
tgid's equality in updt_fd_polling() so that if a change is applied for a
foreing group, then it's detected and taken care of separately. The method
consists in forcing the update on all bound threads in this group, adding it
to the group's update_list, and sending a wake-up as would be done for a
remote thread in the local group, except that this is done by grabbing a
reference to the FD's tgid.
Thanks to this, SIGTTOU/SIGTTIN now work for nbtgroups > 1 (after that was
temporarily broken by "MEDIUM: fd/poller: make the update-list per-group").
With thread groups and group-local masks, the update_mask cannot be
touched nor even checked if it may change below us. In order to avoid
this, we have to grab a reference to the FD's tgid before checking the
update mask. The operations are cheap enough so that we don't notice it
in performance tests. This is expected because the risk of meeting a
reassigned FD during an update remains very low.
It's worth noting that the tgid cannot be trusted during startup nor
during soft-stop since that may come from anywhere at the moment. Since
soft-stop runs under thread isolation we use that hint to decide whether
or not to check that the FD's tgid matches the current one.
The modification is applied to the 3 thread-aware pollers, i.e. epoll,
kqueue, and evports. Also one poll_drop counter was missing for shared
updates, though it might be hard to trigger it.
With this change applied, thread groups are usable in benchmarks.
The poller-specific thread init code now uses that new function to
safely register boot events. This ensures that we don't register an
event for another group and that we properly deal with parallel
thread startup.
It's only done for thread-aware pollers, there's no point in using
that in poll/select though that should work as well.
There's a nasty case during boot, which is the master process. It stops
all listeners from the main thread, and as such we're seeing calls to
fd_delete() from a thread that doesn't match the FD's mask, but more
importantly from a group that doesn't match either. Fortunately this
happens in a process that doesn't see the threads creation, so the FDs
are left intact in the table and we can overwrite the tgid there.
The approach is ugly, it probably shows that we should use a dummy
value for the tgid during boot, that would be replaced once the FDs
migrate to their target, but we also need a way to make sure not to
miss them. Also that doesn't solve the possibility of closing a
listener at run time from the wrong thread group.
At boot the pollers are allocated for each thread and they need to
reprogram updates for all FDs they will manage. This code is not
trivial, especially when trying to respect thread groups, so we'd
rather avoid duplicating it.
Let's centralize this into fd.c with this function. It avoids closed
FDs, those whose thread mask doesn't match the requested one or whose
thread group doesn't match the requested one, and performs the update
if required under thread-group protection.
It requires to both adapt the parser and change the algorithm to
redispatch incoming traffic so that local threads IDs may always
be used.
The internal structures now only reference thread group IDs and
group-local masks which are compatible with those now used by the
FD layer and the rest of the code.
It used to turn group+local to global but now we're doing the exact
opposite as we want to stick to group-local masks. This means that
"thread 3-4" might very well emit what "thread 2/1-2" used to emit
till now for 2 groups and 4 threads. This is needed because we'll
have to support group-local thread masks in receivers.
However the rest of the code (receivers) is not ready yet for this,
so using this code with more than one thread group will definitely
break some bindings.
The IOCB might have closed the FD itself, so it's not an error to
have fd.tgid==0 or anything else, nor to have a null running_mask.
In fact there are different conditions under which we can leave the
IOCB, all of them have been enumerated in the code's comments (namely
FD still valid and used, hence has running bit, FD closed but not yet
reassigned thus running==0, FD closed and reassigned, hence different
tgid and running becomes irrelevant, just like all other masks). For
this reason we have no other solution but to try to grab the tgid on
return before checking the other bits. In practice it doesn't represent
a big cost, because if the FD was closed and reassigned, it's instantly
detected and the bit is immediately released without blocking other
threads, and if the FD wasn't closed this doesn't prevent it from
being migrated to another thread. In the worst case a close by another
thread after a migration will be postponed till the moment the running
bit is cleared, which is the same as before.
These functions need to set/reset the FD's tgid but when they're called
there may still be wakeups on other threads that discover late updates
and have to touch the tgid at the same time. As such, it is not possible
to just read/write the tgid there. It must only be done using operations
that are compatible with what other threads may be doing.
As we're using inc/dec on the refcount, it's safe to AND the area to zero
the lower part when resetting the value. However, in order to set the
value, there's no other choice but fd_claim_tgid() which will assign it
only if possible (via a CAS). This is convenient in the end because it
protects the FD's masks from being modified by late threads, so while
we hold this refcount we can safely reset the thread_mask and a few other
elements. A debug test for non-null masks was added to fd_insert() as it
must not be possible to face this situation thanks to the protection
offered by the tgid.
fd_insert() was already given a thread group ID and a global thread mask.
Now we're changing the few callers to take the group-local thread mask
instead. It's passed directly into the FD's thread mask. Just like for
previous commit, it must not change anything when a single group is
configured.
With the change that was started on other masks, the thread mask was
still not fully converted, sometimes being used as a global mask and
sometimes as a local one. This finishes the code modifications so that
the mask is always considered as a group-local mask. This doesn't
change anything as long as there's a single group, but is necessary
for groups 2 and above since it's used against running_mask and so on.
It's an AND so it destroys information and due to this there's a call
place where we have to perform two reads to know the previous value
then to change it. With a fetch-and-and instead, in a single operation
we can know if the bit was previously present, which is more efficient.
From now on, the FD's running_mask only refers to local thread IDs. However,
there remains a limitation, in updt_fd_polling(), we temporarily have to
check and set shared FDs against .thread_mask, which still contains global
ones. As such, nbtgroups > 1 may break (but this is not yet supported without
special build options).
From now on, the FD's update_mask only refers to local thread IDs. However,
there remains a limitation, in updt_fd_polling(), we temporarily have to
check and set shared FDs against .thread_mask, which still contains global
ones. As such, nbtgroups > 1 may break (but this is not yet supported without
special build options).
This changes the signification of each bit in the polled_mask so that
now each bit represents a local thread ID for the current group instead
of a global thread ID. As such, all tests now apply to ltid_bit instead
of tid_bit.
No particular check was made to verify that the FD's tgid matches the
current one because there should be no case where this is not true. A
check was added in epoll's __fd_clo() to confirm it never differs unless
expected (soft stop under thread isolation, or master in starting mode
going to exec mode), but that doesn't prevent from doing the job: it
only consists in checking in the group's threads those that are still
polling this FD and to remove them.
Some atomic loads were added at the various locations, and most repetitive
references to polled_mask[fd].xx were turned to a local copy instead making
the code much more clear.
We now grab a reference to the FD's tgid before manipulating the
running_mask so that we're certain it corresponds to our own group
(hence bits), and we drop it once we've set the bit. For now there's
no measurable performance impact in doing this, which is great. The
lock can be observed by perf top as taking a small share of the time
spent in fd_update_events(), itself taking no more than 0.28% of CPU
under 8 threads.
However due to the fact that the thread groups are not yet properly
spread across the pollers and the thread masks are still wrong, this
will trigger some BUG_ON() in fd_insert() after a few tens of thousands
of connections when threads other than those of group 1 are reached,
and this is expected.
The file descriptors will need to know the thread group ID in addition
to the mask. This extends fd_insert() to take the tgid, and will store
it into the FD.
In the FD, the tgid is stored as a combination of tgid on the lower 16
bits and a refcount on the higher 16 bits. This allows to know when it's
really possible to trust the tgid and the running mask. If a refcount is
higher than 1 it indeed indicates another thread else might be in the
process of updating these values.
Since a closed FD must necessarily have a zero refcount, a test was
added to fd_insert() to make sure that it is the case.
It's a bit ugly to see that half of the callers of fd_insert() have to
apply all_threads_mask themselves to the bit field they're passing,
because usually it comes from a listener that may have other bits set.
Let's make the function apply the mask itself.
After a poller's ->clo() was called to completely terminate operations
on an FD, there's no reason for keeping updates on this FD, so if any
updates were already programmed it would be nice if we could delete them.
Tests show that __fd_clo() is called roughly half of the time with the
last FD from the local update list, which possibly makes sense if a close
has to appear after a polling change resulting from an incomplete read or
the end of a send().
We can detect this and remove the last entry, which gives less work to
do during the update() call, and eliminates most of the poll_drop_fd
event reports.
Note that while tempting, this must not be backported because it's only
safe to be done now that fd_delete_orphan() clears the update mask as
we need to be certain not to miss it:
- if the update mask is kept up with no entry, we can miss future
updates ;
- if the update mask is cleared too fast, it may result in failure
to add a shared event.
The update-list needs to be per-group because its inspection is based
on a mask and we need to be certain when scanning it if a mask is for
the same thread or another one. Once per-group there's no doubt about
it, even if the FD's polling changes, the entry remains valid. It will
be needed to check the tgid though.
Note that a soft-stop or pause/resume might not necessarily work here
with tgroups>1, because the operation might be delivered to a thread
that doesn't belong to the group and whoe update mask will not reflect
one that is interesting here. We can't do better at this stage.
Dealing with long-lasting updates that outlive a close() is always
going to be quite a problem, not because of the thread that will
discover such updates late, but mostly due to the shared update_list
that will have an entry on hold making it difficult to reuse it, and
requiring that the fd's tgid is changed and the update_mask reset
from a safe location.
After careful inspection, it turns out that all our pollers that support
automatic event removal upon close() do not need any extra bookkeeping,
and that poll and select that use an internal representation already
provide a poller->clo() callback that is already used to update the
local event. As such, it is already safe to reset the update mask and
to remove the event from the shared list just before the final close,
because nothing remains to be done with this FD by the poller.
Doing so considerably simplifies the handling of updates, which will
only have to be inspected by the pollers, while the writers can continue
to consider that the entries are always valid. Another benefit is that
it will be possible to reduce contention on the update_list by just
having one update_list per group (left to be done later if needed).
We don't want to pick idle connections from another thread group,
this would be very slow by forcing to share undesirable data.
This patch makes sure that we start seeking from the current thread
group's threads only and loops over that range exclusively.
It's worth noting that the next_takeover pointer remains per-server
and will bounce when multiple groups use it at the same time. But we
preserve the perturbation by applying a modulo when retrieving it,
so that when groups are of the same size (most common case), the
index will not even change. At this time it doesn't seem worth
storing one index per group in servers, but that might be an option
if any contention is detected later.
This one is only used as a hint to improve scheduling latency, so there
is no more point in keeping it global since each thread group handles
its own run q
Their migration was postponed for convenience only but now's time for
having the shared wait queues per thread group and not just per process,
otherwise the WQ lock uses a huge amount of CPU alone.
Since commit d2494e048 ("BUG/MEDIUM: peers/config: properly set the
thread mask") there must not remain any single case of a receiver that
is bound nowhere, so there's no need anymore for thread_mask().
We're adding a test in fd_insert() to make sure this doesn't happen by
accident though, but the function was removed and its rare uses were
replaced with the original value of the bind_thread msak.
When using multiple groups, the stats socket starts to emit errors and
it's not natural to have to touch the global section just to specify
"thread 1/all". Let's pre-attach these sockets to thread group 1. This
will cause errors when trying to change the group but this really is not
a problem for now as thread groups are not enabled by default. This will
make sure configs remain portable and may possibly be relaxed later.
As a side effect of commit 34aae2fd1 ("MEDIUM: mworker: set the iocb of
the socketpair without using fd_insert()"), a config may now refuse to
start if there are multiple groups configured because the default bind
mask may span over multiple groups, and it is not possible to force it
to work differently.
Let's just assign thread group 1 to the master<->worker sockets so that
the thread bindings automatically resolve to a single group. The same was
done for the master side of the socket even if it's not used. It will
avoid being forgotten in the future.
The principle remains the same, but instead of having a single process
and ignoring extra ones, now we set the affinity masks for the respective
threads of all groups.
The doc was updated with a few extra examples.
These old legacy pollers are not designed for this. They're still
using a shared list of events for all threads, this will not scale at
all, so there's no point in enabling thread-groups there. Modern
systems have epoll, kqueue or event ports and do not need these ones.
We arrange for failing at boot time, only when thread-groups > 1 so
that existing setups will remain unaffected.
If there's a compelling reason for supporting thread groups with these
pollers in the future, the rework should not be too hard, it would just
consume a lot of memory to have an fd_evts[] array per thread, but that
is doable.
When an FD is migrated, all pollers program an update. That's useless
code duplication, and when thread groups will be supported, this will
require an extra round of locking just to verify the update_mask on
return. Let's just program the update direction from fd_update_events()
as it already does for closed FDs, this becomes more logical.
protocol_stop_now() is called from do_soft_stop_now() running on any
thread that received the signal. The problem is that it will call some
listener handlers to close the FD, resulting in an fd_delete() being
called from the wrong group. That's not clean and we cannot even rely
on the thread mask to show up.
One interesting long-term approach could be to have kill queues for
FDs, and maybe we'll need them in the long run. However that doesn't
work well for listeners in this situation.
Let's simply isolate ourselves during this instant. We know we'll be
alone dealing with the close and that the FD will be instantly deleted
since not in use by any other thread. It's not the cleanest solution
but it should last long enough without causing trouble.
Since we have to use masks to verify owners/waiters, we have no other
option but to have them per group. This definitely inflates the size
of the locks, but this is only used for extreme debugging anyway so
that's not dramatic.
Thus as of now, all masks in the lock stats are local bit masks, derived
from ti->ltid_bit. Since at boot ltid_bit might not be set, we just take
care of this situation (since some structs are initialized under look
during boot), and use bit 0 from group 0 only.
