Stream interfaces used to distinguish between client and server addresses
because they were previously of different types (sockaddr_storage for the
client, sockaddr_in for the server). This is not the case anymore, and this
distinction is confusing at best and has caused a number of regressions to
be introduced in the process of converting everything to full-ipv6. We can
now remove this and have a much cleaner code.
This patch introduces hdr_len, path_len and url_len for matching these
respective parts lengths against integers. This can be used to detect
abuse or empty headers.
Commit 588bd4 fixed header parsing so that trailing spaces were not part
of the returned string. Unfortunately, if a header only had spaces, the
last spaces were trimmed past the beginning of the value, causing a negative
length to be returned.
A quick code review shows that there should be no impact since the only
places where the vlen is used are either compared to a specific value or
with explicit contents (eg: digits).
This must be backported to 1.4.
These requests are mainly monitor requests, as well as stats requests when
the stats are processed by the frontend. Having this counter helps explain
the difference in number of sessions that is sometimes observed between a
frontend and a backend.
Sometimes a bad content-length header is encountered and this causes
an abort. It's hard to debug without a trace, so let's take a capture
of the contents when this happens.
If a server starts to respond but stops before the body, then we
capture the truncated response. We don't do this on the request
because it would happen too often upon stupid attacks.
Trailing spaces after headers were not trimmed, only the leading ones
were. An issue was detected today with a content-length value which
was padded with spaces and which was rejected. Recent updates to the
http-bis draft made it a lot more clear that such spaces must be ignored,
so this is what this patch does.
It should be backported to 1.4.
Many inet_ntop calls were partially right, which was hard to detect given
the complex combinations. Some of them were relying on the listener's proto
instead of the address itself, which could have been different when dealing
with an accept-proxy connection.
The new addr_to_str() function does the dirty job and returns the family, which
makes it particularly suited to calls from switch/case statements. A large number
of if/else statements were removed and the stats output could even be cleaned up
in the case of session dump.
As a side effect of doing this, the resulting code is smaller by almost 1kB.
All changed parts have been tested and provided expected output.
If "option forwardfor" has the "if-none" argument, then the header is
only added when the request did not already have one. This option has
security implications, and should not be set blindly.
This is used to perform cookie-based stickiness with table replication
between multiple masters and across restarts. This partially overrides
some of the appsession capabilities.
The motivation for this is to allow iteration of all the connections
of a server without the expense of iterating over the global list
of connections.
The first use of this will be to implement an option to close connections
associated with a server when is is marked as being down or in maintenance
mode.
gcc (Debian 4.6.0-2) 4.6.1 20110329 (prerelease)
Copyright (C) 2011 Free Software Foundation, Inc.
This is free software; see the source for copying conditions. There is NO
warranty; not even for MERCHANTABILITY or FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE.
...
src/proto_http.c:3029:14: warning: variable ‘del_cl’ set but not used [-Wunused-but-set-variable]
In file included from ebtree/eb64tree.c:23:0:
ebtree/eb64tree.h: In function ‘__eb64_lookup’:
ebtree/eb64tree.h:128:6: warning: variable ‘node_bit’ set but not used [-Wunused-but-set-variable]
ebtree/eb64tree.h: In function ‘__eb64i_lookup’:
ebtree/eb64tree.h:180:6: warning: variable ‘node_bit’ set but not used [-Wunused-but-set-variable]
In file included from ebtree/ebpttree.h:26:0,
from ebtree/ebimtree.c:23:
ebtree/eb64tree.h: In function ‘__eb64_lookup’:
ebtree/eb64tree.h:128:6: warning: variable ‘node_bit’ set but not used [-Wunused-but-set-variable]
ebtree/eb64tree.h: In function ‘__eb64i_lookup’:
ebtree/eb64tree.h:180:6: warning: variable ‘node_bit’ set but not used [-Wunused-but-set-variable]
In file included from ebtree/ebpttree.h:26:0,
from ebtree/ebistree.h:25,
from ebtree/ebistree.c:23:
ebtree/eb64tree.h: In function ‘__eb64_lookup’:
ebtree/eb64tree.h:128:6: warning: variable ‘node_bit’ set but not used [-Wunused-but-set-variable]
ebtree/eb64tree.h: In function ‘__eb64i_lookup’:
ebtree/eb64tree.h:180:6: warning: variable ‘node_bit’ set but not used [-Wunused-but-set-variable]
Bashkim Kasa reported that the stats admin page did not work when colons
were used in server or backend names. This was caused by url-encoding
resulting in ':' being sent as '%3A'. Now we systematically decode the
field names and values to fix this issue.
Now that we support the http-no-delay mode, we can optimize HTTP
chunking again by always waiting for more data to come until the
last chunk is met.
This patch may or may not be backported to 1.4, it's not a big deal,
it will mainly help for chunks which are aligned with the buffer size.
There are some very rare server-to-server applications that abuse the HTTP
protocol and expect the payload phase to be highly interactive, with many
interleaved data chunks in both directions within a single request. This is
absolutely not supported by the HTTP specification and will not work across
most proxies or servers. When such applications attempt to do this through
haproxy, it works but they will experience high delays due to the network
optimizations which favor performance by instructing the system to wait for
enough data to be available in order to only send full packets. Typical
delays are around 200 ms per round trip. Note that this only happens with
abnormal uses. Normal uses such as CONNECT requests nor WebSockets are not
affected.
When "option http-no-delay" is present in either the frontend or the backend
used by a connection, all such optimizations will be disabled in order to
make the exchanges as fast as possible. Of course this offers no guarantee on
the functionality, as it may break at any other place. But if it works via
HAProxy, it will work as fast as possible. This option should never be used
by default, and should never be used at all unless such a buggy application
is discovered. The impact of using this option is an increase of bandwidth
usage and CPU usage, which may significantly lower performance in high
latency environments.
This change should be backported to 1.4 since the first report of such a
misuse was in 1.4. Next patch will also be needed.
Commit 57f5c1 used to provide a nice improvement on chunked encoding since
it ensured that we did not set a PUSH flag for every chunk or buffer data
part of a chunked transfer.
Some applications appear to erroneously abuse HTTP chunking in order to
get interactive exchanges between a user agent and an origin server with
very small chunks. While it happens to work through haproxy, it's terribly
slow due to the latency added after passing each chunk to the system, who
could wait up to 200ms before pushing them onto the wire.
So we need an interactive mode for such usages. In the mean time, step back
on the optim, but not completely, so that we still keep the flag as long as
we know we're not finished with the current chunk.
This change should be backported to 1.4 too as the issue was discovered
with it.
This status code is used in response to requests matching "monitor-uri".
Some users need to adjust it to fit their needs (eg: make some strings
appear there). As it's already defined as a chunked string and used
exactly like other status codes, it makes sense to make it configurable
with the usual "errorfile", "errorloc", ...
Some people like to make the monitoring URL testable from unsafe locations.
Reporting haproxy's existence there can sometimes be problematic. This patch
should not be backported to 1.4 because it is possible, eventhough unlikely,
that some scripts rely on this word to appear there.
When doing fix 24581bae022bcf97ea7818e49ef27d21c92d6aa3 to correctly handle
response cookies, an unfortunate typo was inserted in the less likely code
path, resulting in a risk of crash when cookie-based persistence is enabled
and the server emits a cookie with several spaces around the equal sign.
This bug was noticed during a code backport. Its effects were never reported
because this situation is very unlikely to appear, but it can be provoked on
purpose by the server.
This patch must be backported to 1.4 versions which contain the fix above
(anything > 1.4.8), and to similar 1.3 versions > 1.3.25. 1.5-dev versions
after 1.5-dev2 are affected too.
Despite much care around handling the content-length as a 64-bit integer,
forwarding was broken on 32-bit platforms due to the 32-bit nature of
the ->to_forward member of the "buffer" struct. The issue is that this
member is declared as a long, so while it works OK on 64-bit platforms,
32-bit truncate the content-length to the lower 32-bits.
One solution could consist in turning to_forward to a long long, but it
is used a lot in the critical path, so it's not acceptable to perform
all buffer size computations on 64-bit there.
The fix consists in changing the to_forward member to a strict 32-bit
integer and ensure in buffer_forward() that only the amount of bytes
that can fit into it is considered. Callers of buffer_forward() are
responsible for checking that their data were taken into account. We
arbitrarily ensure we never consider more than 2G at once.
That's the way it was intended to work on 32-bit platforms except that
it did not.
This issue was tracked down hard at Exosec with Bertrand Jacquin,
Thierry Fournier and Julien Thomas. It remained undetected for a long
time because files larger than 4G are almost always transferred in
chunked-encoded format, and most platforms dealing with huge contents
these days run on 64-bit.
The bug affects all 1.5 and 1.4 versions, and must be backported.
Since we now have the copy of the target in the session, use it instead
of relying on the SI for it. The SI drops the target upon unregister()
so applets such as stats were logged as "NOSRV".
Johannes Smith reported some wrong retries count in logs associated with bad
requests. The cause was that the conn_retries field in the stream interface
was only initialized when attempting to connect, but is used when logging,
possibly with an uninitialized value holding last connection's conn_retries.
This could have been avoided by making use of a stream interface initializer.
This bug is 1.5-specific.
And also rename "req_acl_rule" "http_req_rule". At the beginning that
was a bit confusing to me, especially the "req_acl" list which in fact
holds what we call rules. After some digging, it appeared that some
part of the code is 100% HTTP and not just related to authentication
anymore, so let's move that part to HTTP and keep the auth-only code
in auth.c.
Right now, http-request rules are not evaluated if the URL matches the
stats request. This is quite unexpected. For instance, in the config
below, an abuser present in the abusers list will not be prevented access
to the stats.
listen pub
bind :8181
acl abuser src -f abusers.lst
http-request deny if abuser
stats uri /stats
It is not a big deal but it's not documented as such either. For 1.5, let's
have both lists be evaluated in turn, until one blocks. For 1.4 we'll simply
update the doc to indicate that.
Also instead of duplicating the code, the patch factors out the list walking
code. The HTTP auth has been moved slightly earlier, because it was set after
the header addition code, but we don't need to add headers to a request we're
dropping.
It's very annoying that frontend and backend stats are merged because we
don't know what we're observing. For instance, if a "listen" instance
makes use of a distinct backend, it's impossible to know what the bytes_out
means.
Some points take care of not updating counters twice if the backend points
to the frontend, indicating a "listen" instance. The thing becomes more
complex when we try to add support for server side keep-alive, because we
have to maintain a pointer to the backend used for last request, and to
update its stats. But we can't perform such comparisons anymore because
the counters will not match anymore.
So in order to get rid of this situation, let's have both frontend AND
backend stats in the "struct proxy". We simply update the relevant ones
during activity. Some of them are only accounted for in the backend,
while others are just for frontend. Maybe we can improve a bit on that
later, but the essential part is that those counters now reflect what
they really mean.
This patch turns internal server addresses to sockaddr_storage to
store IPv6 addresses, and makes the connect() function use it. This
code already works but some caveats with getaddrinfo/gethostbyname
still need to be sorted out while the changes had to be merged at
this stage of internal architecture changes. So for now the config
parser will not emit an IPv6 address yet so that user experience
remains unchanged.
This change should have absolutely zero user-visible effect, otherwise
it's a bug introduced during the merge, that should be reported ASAP.
This one has been removed and is now totally superseded by ->target.
To get the server, one must use target_srv(&s->target) instead of
s->srv now.
The function ensures that non-server targets still return NULL.
s->prev_srv is used by assign_server() only, but all code paths leading
to it now take s->prev_srv from the existing s->srv. So assign_server()
can do that copy into its own stack.
If at one point a different srv is needed, we still have a copy of the
last server on which we failed a connection attempt in s->target.
When dealing with HTTP keep-alive, we'll have to know if we can reuse
an existing connection. For that, we'll have to check if the current
connection was made on the exact same target (referenced in the stream
interface).
Thus, we need to first assign the next target to the session, then
copy it to the stream interface upon connect(). Later we'll check for
equivalence between those two operations.
This is in fact where those parts belong to. The old data_state was replaced
by applet.state and is now initialized when the applet is registered. It's
worth noting that the applet does not need to know the session nor the
buffer anymore since everything is brought by the stream interface.
It is possible that having a separate applet struct would simplify the
code but that's not a big deal.
With HTTP keep-alive, logging the right server name will be quite
complex because the assigned server will possibly change before we log.
Also, when we want to log accesses to an applet, it's not easy because
the applet becomes NULL again before logging.
The logged server's name is now taken from the target stored in the
stream interface. That way we can log an applet, a server name, or we
could even log a proxy or anything else if we wanted to. Ideally the
session should contain a desired target which is the one which should
be logged.
I/O handlers are still delicate to manipulate. They have no type, they're
just raw functions which have no knowledge of themselves. Let's have them
declared as applets once for all. That way we can have multiple applets
share the same handler functions and we can store their names there. When
we later need to add more parameters (eg: usage stats), we'll be able to
do so in the applets themselves.
The CLI functions has been prefixed with "cli" instead of "stats" as it's
clearly what is going on there.
The applet descriptor in the stream interface should get all the applet
specific data (st0, ...) but this will be done in the next patch so that
we don't pollute this one too much.
Similar to the stats socket bug, we must check that the proxy is not disabled
before trying to enable/disable a server.
Even if a disabled proxy is not displayed, someone can inject a faulty proxy
name in the POST parameters. So, we must ensure that no disabled proxy can be
used.
Bryan Talbot reported that POST requests with a query string were not
correctly processed if the hash parameter was the first one, because
the delimiter that was looked for to trigger the parsing was '&' instead
of '?'.
Also, while checking the code, it became apparent that it was enough for
a query string to be present in the request for POST parameters to be
ignored, even if the url_param was in the body and not in the URL.
The code has then been fixed like this :
1) look for URL param. If found, return it.
2) if no URL param was found and method is POST, then look it up into
the body
The code now seems to pass all request combinations.
This patch must be backported to 1.4 since 1.4 is equally broken right now.
Till now, the forwarding code was making use of the hdr_content_len member
to hold the size of the last chunk parsed. As such, it was reset after being
scheduled for forwarding. The issue is that this entry was reset before the
data could be viewed by backend.c in order to parse a POST body, so the
"balance url_param check_post" did not work anymore.
In order to fix this, we need two things :
- the chunk size (reset upon every forward)
- the total body size (not reset)
hdr_content_len was thus replaced by the former (hence the size of the patch)
as it makes more sense to have it stored that way than the way around.
This patch should be backported to 1.4 with care, considering that it affects
the forwarding code.
It seems like if a response message is chunked and the chunk size wraps
at the end of the buffer and the crlf sequence is incomplete, then we
can forward a wrong chunk size due to incorrect handling of the wrapped
size. It seems extremely unlikely to occur on real traffic (no reason to
have half of the CRLF after a chunk) but nothing prevents it from being
possible.
This fix must be backported to 1.4.
req_acl was used instead of req_acl_final. As a matter of luck, both
happen to be the same at this point, but this is not granted in the
future.
This fix should be backported to 1.4.
Some browsers send POST requests in several packets, which was not supported
by the "stats admin" function.
This patch allows to wait for more data when they are not fully received
(we are still limited to a certain size defined by the buffer size minus its
reserved space).
It also adds support for the "Expect: 100-Continue" header.
Stefan Behte reported a strange case where depending on the position of
the Connection header in the header list, some headers added after it
were or were not usable in "balance hdr()". The reason is that when the
last header is removed, the list's tail was not updated, so any header
added after that one was not visible from the list.
This fix must be backported to 1.4 and possibly 1.3.
It's better to avoid sticking on empty parameter values, as this almost
always indicates a missing parameter. Otherwise it's easy to enter a
situation where all new visitors stick to the same server.
Since haproxy 1.4.9, combining option httpclose and option
http-pretend-keepalive can leave the connections opened until the backend
keep-alive timeout is reached, providing bad performances.
The same can occur when the proxy is in tunnel mode.
This patch ensures that the server side connection is closed after the
response and ignore http-pretend-keepalive in tunnel mode.
